For a few months in 1848 it seemed that Germans might do by debate what their princes had never done by war: build one nation out of dozens of states. The attempt was earnest, learned and in the end powerless, and its story is one of the great case studies in what a parliament can and cannot do without force behind it.
From Heidelberg to St Paul's Church
In early March a group of liberals met at Heidelberg and called for a national parliament. A preliminary assembly gathered in Frankfurt at the end of the month and arranged elections across the German Confederation. Radicals who wanted a republic at once lost the argument. In April one of them, the lawyer Friedrich Hecker, led an armed rising in Baden, and it was quickly beaten.
The National Assembly opened on 18 May 1848 in Frankfurt's oval St Paul's Church. Its members were overwhelmingly men of education: judges, officials, lawyers, teachers and professors, with few artisans and almost no peasants or factory workers. Deputies grouped themselves into loose parties named after the inns and cafés where they met. Heinrich von Gagern, a liberal from Hesse, was elected president.
Germany had no government, so the assembly invented one. In June it elected Archduke John of Austria as Imperial Regent, a Habsburg prince popular for his simple manners and liberal reputation, and he appointed ministers. But this provisional central power had no army or taxes of its own. It could pass resolutions; only the states could carry them out.
The test of Schleswig-Holstein
The weakness showed within months. The duchies of Schleswig and Holstein were ruled by the Danish king, but Holstein belonged to the German Confederation and both had many German speakers. When Denmark moved to bind Schleswig more closely, Germans there revolted, and Prussian troops marched north in the name of the nation. Then, under pressure from Britain and Russia, Prussia signed the armistice of Malmö in August, which ended its war with Denmark without Frankfurt's consent.
The assembly first rejected the armistice, then, realizing it could not fight Denmark alone, accepted it. Radicals in Frankfurt called this a betrayal. On 18 September crowds attacked the assembly, and rioters murdered two conservative deputies, Prince Felix Lichnowsky and General Hans von Auerswald. The assembly was saved by Prussian and Austrian troops, the very forces it hoped to replace.
The Basic Rights
The deputies spent months on a bill of rights, and many historians now think this was time well used. The Basic Rights of the German People, passed in December 1848, abolished the legal privileges of the nobility as an estate, guaranteed freedom of the press, of assembly and of belief, protected scholarship and teaching, and abolished the death penalty except under martial law. They also declared that civil rights did not depend on religion. The Hamburg lawyer Gabriel Riesser, a Jew, served as a vice-president of the assembly, a sign of how far opinion had moved.
Liberty for Germans did not always mean respect for others. When the assembly debated the Prussian province of Posen, where Poles had risen and been crushed, it voted to include most of the province in Germany. The future of the Czechs of Bohemia, who mostly refused to send deputies, was treated in the same spirit.
A crown refused
In November 1848 Robert Blum, a popular radical deputy from Leipzig, was in Vienna when Windischgrätz took the city. He was court-martialed and shot. His execution shocked Frankfurt because he was a deputy shot despite his immunity, and the assembly could do nothing about it.
The constitution was finished in March 1849. It created a hereditary emperor and a lower house elected by all adult men. Having settled on the Lesser Germany plan, a united Germany without Austria, the deputies chose the king of Prussia as emperor, and in April a delegation travelled to Berlin to offer him the crown. He refused. Twenty-eight smaller states accepted the constitution, but the larger kingdoms did not. Uprisings in its defense broke out in Saxony, the Palatinate and Baden in May. A rump of the assembly moved to Stuttgart and was dispersed by Württemberg troops in June. In July the Baden revolutionaries surrendered the fortress of Rastatt to the Prussian army.
Worked example: Greater or Lesser Germany?
Every map of a united Germany ran into the same problem: Austria. The Habsburg monarchy contained German lands that had belonged to the confederation, but also Hungary, Croatia, Galicia and northern Italy. What should the deputies draw?
The "Greater Germany" answer brought in Austria's German lands. That would split the Habsburg monarchy in two, or else drag millions of Czechs, Slovenes and Italians into a German state. The "Lesser Germany" answer was a united Germany without Austria, almost certainly led by Prussia. It was cleaner, but it left out millions of German-speaking Austrians and handed a mostly Catholic south to a Protestant Prussian king.
In the end Vienna decided the question for Frankfurt. In March 1849 the Austrian government issued a constitution binding all its lands into one centralized state, which made the greater solution impossible. The assembly turned to Prussia by a narrow majority. When the Prussian king refused, the lesser solution waited until 1871, when Bismarck built it through three wars. The deputies had foreseen the map. They had lacked the means to draw it.
