Skip to main content

After the defeat of 1895

The loss to Japan shocked educated Chinese more deeply than any earlier defeat. A smaller Asian neighbor had modernized faster and beaten the Qing at its own game. In Beijing, examination candidates signed petitions against the peace terms, organized in part by the scholar Kang Youwei. Historians still debate how many signed and whether the main petition was ever formally submitted, but the episode showed scholars acting together on national affairs.

The foreign powers moved quickly to exploit the weakness. In 1897, after two German missionaries were killed in Shandong, Germany seized the bay of Jiaozhou and forced a lease. Russia, Britain and France soon took leases and spheres of influence of their own.

A hundred days

In the summer of 1898 the young Guangxu emperor, influenced by Kang Youwei and his student Liang Qichao, issued a flood of reform edicts on schools, the examinations, the army and the bureaucracy. In September Cixi and her allies struck back. Guangxu spent the rest of his life under confinement in the palace grounds. Kang and Liang escaped to Japan. Tan Sitong, a young reformer, refused to flee and was executed, saying that no reform in any country had succeeded without bloodshed, and that he would be the first in China to shed his.

The Boxers and the south

In 1900 an anti-foreign movement known to foreigners as the Boxers spread across the north China plain, and Cixi's court declared war on the foreign powers. Not all of the empire followed. The leading governors-general of the Yangzi valley and the south ignored the declaration of war and agreed with foreign consuls to keep order in their regions. It also showed that great provincial officials could now act on their own judgment against the throne.

The New Policies

After defeat in 1900 the court that had crushed reform adopted much of it. The New Policies of the 1900s created modern schools and ministries, trained a New Army on Western lines and sent thousands of students to Japan. After Japan defeated Russia in 1905, many concluded that constitutions made nations strong. In 1908 the court issued an outline constitution with a program of nine years of preparation for parliament. Provincial assemblies, elected by a very small electorate of property owners and degree holders, met in 1909, and a national assembly in 1910.

Then the court lost much of the goodwill it had earned. In May 1911 it named its first cabinet, and most of its ministers were Manchus, several of them imperial princes. Critics called it the Princes' Cabinet.

Revolutionaries

Others had given up on the dynasty altogether. Revolutionary groups, many led by Sun Yat-sen from exile, staged uprising after uprising, and all failed. One of the most famous revolutionaries was Qiu Jin, who left an arranged marriage, studied in Japan, wore Western men's clothing, wrote poetry, ran a women's journal and taught at a school that trained rebels. In 1907 she was arrested and beheaded after a failed rising, becoming a martyr for both the revolution and the cause of women's equality.

The end

Revolution came in 1911 through an unplanned mutiny at Wuchang, and province after province declared its independence. The court recalled the general Yuan Shikai, who negotiated with both sides. On 12 February 1912 an edict issued in the name of the six-year-old emperor ended more than two thousand years of imperial rule. Under the Articles of Favorable Treatment, the former emperor kept his title, a yearly allowance and a home in the Forbidden City.

The new republic claimed all the lands the Qing had ruled. Its five-colored flag stood for five peoples: Han, Manchu, Mongol, Hui and Tibetan, a promise of equality that was easier to fly than to keep. Manchus in several garrison cities had been massacred during the revolution, and many others hid their identity for decades. The Qing's boundaries, its frontiers in Inner Asia and its unresolved questions about who belongs to the nation shaped the China that followed.

Worked example: a railway and a revolution

How did a dispute over railways bring down a dynasty? In 1911 the court decided to nationalize two trunk lines, one of them in Sichuan, so it could borrow from a consortium of foreign banks to build them. Sichuan investors, many of them gentry and ordinary landowners who had been made to buy shares through a tax surcharge, were offered compensation they thought unfair. They formed a Railway Protection League, held mass meetings, closed shops and refused taxes.

In September troops in Chengdu fired on protesters, killing dozens, and the province rose. To restore order the court sent units of the New Army from Hubei into Sichuan. That left the garrisons around Wuchang thinner and more restless. When an accidental bomb blast exposed a revolutionary cell in the city on 9 October, soldiers who feared arrest mutinied the next day.

Each step in the chain was local and in part accidental. Yet each depended on deeper conditions: a court that needed foreign money, provincial elites who had learned to organize through the new assemblies, and an army whose loyalty had worn thin. Big events often arrive through small doors, but only when the house is already weakened.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Germany do in 1897 after two missionaries were killed in Shandong?
2. What did Tan Sitong do when the reforms of 1898 were crushed?
3. How did the leading southern governors-general respond to the war declaration of 1900?
4. What did the outline constitution of 1908 promise?
5. Why was the cabinet of May 1911 called the Princes' Cabinet?
6. What happened to Qiu Jin in 1907?
7. What did the Articles of Favorable Treatment allow the former emperor?
8. Which peoples did the five-colored flag of the new republic stand for?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia