Cracks in the system
The Jiaqing emperor, who ruled in his own right from 1799, inherited a treasury drained by Heshen's corruption and by a long religious rebellion in the central provinces. He purged Heshen but could not purge the habits of a bureaucracy that had grown used to fees and favors. Then danger reached the palace itself. In 1813 members of a sect called the Eight Trigrams, helped by eunuchs inside, broke into the Forbidden City. The emperor was away, and the young prince who later became the Daoguang emperor shot at the attackers with a musket and helped drive them off.
The great works that held the empire together were failing too. The Grand Canal silted up, and in 1855 the Yellow River broke its dikes and shifted to a new mouth north of the Shandong peninsula, flooding wide areas and cutting the canal. The state, at war on many fronts, could not afford to put it back. Meanwhile opium imports drained silver abroad, and two wars with Britain and France opened ports and imposed treaties.
Rebellions on every side
The middle of the century brought the deadliest civil wars of the age. The Taiping war in the south and center cost tens of millions of lives. Nian bands raided across the north. In the southwest and northwest, Muslim communities rose after years of local violence, and in the northwest the fighting from 1862 to 1873 emptied whole districts. In Xinjiang a commander from Central Asia, Yakub Beg, set up his own state.
Whether to reconquer Xinjiang split the court in 1874 and 1875. Li Hongzhang, the leading official in the north, argued that money was better spent on coastal defense against the sea powers. The general Zuo Zongtang argued that losing Xinjiang would endanger Mongolia and Beijing itself. The court backed Zuo. His army retook the region by 1878, Russia handed back most of the Ili valley by treaty in 1881, and in 1884 Xinjiang was made a regular province of the empire.
Self-Strengthening
The wars persuaded some officials that China needed Western weapons and the knowledge behind them. The program they began in the 1860s is called Self-Strengthening. In Beijing a school for foreign languages opened in 1862. When it proposed adding astronomy and mathematics in 1867, the grand secretary Woren objected that a nation's strength lay in propriety and righteousness, not technique.
In the provinces, officials built arsenals and shipyards: a great arsenal at Shanghai from 1865, a navy yard at Fuzhou from 1866. A steamship line founded in 1872 was run on a formula called official supervision and merchant management: merchants put up capital and ran operations, while officials protected the firm and took a hand in it. The official Zhang Zhidong later summed up the program's logic as Chinese learning for the essentials and Western learning for practical use.
Defeat at sea
The new forces were tested and found wanting. In 1884, in a war with France over Vietnam, a French squadron destroyed the Fujian fleet at its Mawei anchorage, near Fuzhou, within about an hour. In 1894 and 1895 a war with Japan over Korea brought a worse disaster. The northern fleet, built with German and British ships, was beaten at sea and then trapped and taken at its own base.
Historians long blamed Empress Dowager Cixi, who dominated the court, for diverting navy funds to rebuild a palace garden near Beijing. Some money was indeed shifted, though how much, and how much it mattered, is disputed. Divided command, poor training and a lack of coordination between regional fleets mattered at least as much. In 1957 the historian Mary Wright argued that the Self-Strengthening and the restoration of order after the rebellions failed because the needs of modernization clashed with the Confucian order itself. Later historians have stressed instead what was achieved, and how much depended on politics and money.
Worked example: the boys who went to America
In 1872 the first of four groups of Chinese boys sailed for the United States. The plan was the work of Yung Wing, who in 1854 had become the first Chinese graduate of Yale. Over four years, 120 boys, thirty a year, were placed with families in New England to study for about fifteen years and return as engineers, officers and diplomats.
The boys learned English quickly, played baseball and did well in school. To conservative supervisors, they were becoming too American: some cut their queues, some converted to Christianity, and many neglected their Chinese studies. At the same time the United States was turning against Chinese immigrants, and American military academies refused to admit the students. In 1881 the court recalled them all.
The recall looks like failure, yet the returned students became railway builders, naval officers, mining engineers and, in one case, the first premier of the Republic of China. Zhan Tianyou, one of them, built the railway from Beijing to Zhangjiakou with Chinese engineers alone. The case shows Self-Strengthening's tension in miniature: the court wanted Western skill without Western habits, and found the two hard to separate.
