Between 1880 and 1920 more than twenty million immigrants arrived in the United States. In 1910 about one in seven people living in the country had been born abroad. Earlier immigrants had come mostly from Britain, Ireland, Germany and Scandinavia. Now many came from Italy, Austria-Hungary, the Russian Empire, Greece and the Ottoman lands, and smaller numbers from China, Japan and Mexico. Most were poor, and most went where the jobs were: the mills, mines, packinghouses and garment shops of fast-growing cities.
Arrival
For Europeans, the gateway was New York harbor. Ellis Island opened as a federal immigration station on 1 January 1892, and over the next decades millions passed through its halls, where doctors checked for contagious disease and inspectors asked questions about work and money. Only about two percent were turned away. On the West Coast, Asian immigrants faced a far harsher system. Chinese laborers had been barred by law since 1882, and at the Angel Island station in San Francisco Bay, opened in 1910, Chinese arrivals could be held for weeks or months while officials tried to catch false claims of family ties. Some carved poems of anger and homesickness into the barrack walls.
Why they came, and what they found
Historians speak of push and pull. Rising populations, falling grain prices and land shortages pushed peasants out of southern Italy and Galicia, and pogroms pushed Jews out of the Russian Empire. Cheap steamship fares and letters from relatives already in America pulled them across. Many did not mean to stay. Large shares of Italian and Balkan men, called birds of passage, worked a few seasons and returned home with savings. Those who stayed built mutual aid societies, parishes, synagogues, newspapers and small banks of their own, which eased the shock of arrival.
The city they found was crowded beyond anything Americans had known. Chicago grew from about 300,000 people in 1870 to more than two million by 1910. The 1920 census was the first to count more Americans living in urban places than in rural ones. New immigrants packed into tenements, buildings of four to six stories crammed onto narrow lots, where whole families lived in two or three rooms and shared a toilet in the hall or yard.
Exposing the slums
The Danish-born journalist Jacob Riis made those conditions visible. Using newly invented flash photography, he photographed dark rooms, alleys and lodging houses of New York's Lower East Side. His 1890 book How the Other Half Lives shocked middle-class readers and helped push the state toward reform, although his descriptions of ethnic groups were often full of stereotypes. New York's Tenement House Act of 1901 required new buildings to have a window opening to the outside air in every room, and toilets inside each apartment.
Others went to live among the poor. Settlement houses, staffed largely by college-educated women, offered kindergartens, English classes, clinics and public baths, and gathered data for reform. Lillian Wald, a nurse, founded the Henry Street Settlement in New York in 1893 and built a visiting nurse service that brought care into tenement homes. By 1910 there were more than four hundred settlements across the country.
The nativist reaction
Many native-born Americans feared that the newcomers, mostly Catholic, Jewish or Orthodox, could never become true Americans. The Immigration Restriction League, founded in Boston in 1894, campaigned for a literacy test to keep out the poorest and least schooled. Presidents vetoed such tests several times, until Congress overrode Woodrow Wilson's veto in 1917. The government's Dillingham Commission produced a vast study, published in 1911, that ranked new immigrants as less desirable than old ones. Japanese immigration was limited by a diplomatic understanding of 1907 and 1908 known as the Gentlemen's Agreement. Defenders of restriction spoke of protecting wages and social harmony. Critics, then and now, see a mix of real economic worry and theories of racial rank that science later rejected.
Worked example: a family on Orchard Street
Picture a Jewish family from a town in the Russian Empire who reach the Lower East Side in 1905. The father finds work through a cousin in a small garment shop, a sweatshop paid by the piece. The mother finishes trousers at home by lamplight, and the eldest daughter, fourteen, lies about her age to work at a sewing machine. They share three rooms with a boarder to make the rent. The younger children attend a public school that teaches in English, and the daughter takes evening classes at a settlement house.
Each part of the city's machinery touches them. The landlord profits from crowding that the 1901 law will slowly limit. The ward boss of the local political machine helps the father get a peddler's license in return for his vote once he is naturalized. The settlement offers English and a library, and records the family's budget for a report on wages. The family's story is neither pure misery nor easy success. It is a hard climb, made partly by their own work and networks, and partly by reformers who believed that the conditions of city life were a public responsibility.
