Gilded Age politics has a poor reputation. The presidents of the period, from Rutherford B. Hayes to Benjamin Harrison, are among the least remembered in American history, and critics then and since described politics as a contest over offices rather than ideas. Yet ordinary Americans cared intensely. Turnout in presidential elections regularly reached about 80 percent of eligible voters, far higher than in most later periods. To understand the age one has to see why politics mattered so much to people and why it still failed to answer the questions industry was raising.
Loyal armies of voters
Voters attached themselves to parties much as fans attach to teams today, often for life and often for reasons of religion, region and memory. Republicans held most of the North, drew on Protestant and Union veteran loyalties, and reminded voters which party had saved the nation. The habit of reminding Northern voters of Confederate treason and Union sacrifice was called "waving the bloody shirt." Democrats held the white South and many Catholic immigrants in Northern cities. Campaigns were spectacles of torchlight parades, brass bands and picnics, and parties printed their own ballots in their own colors, so a voter's choice was visible to anyone watching.
Because the parties were so evenly matched, elections were close. In 1876 and again in 1888 the candidate who lost the popular vote won the presidency in the Electoral College. Control of Congress changed hands repeatedly, and neither party could govern for long. Close contests encouraged both sides to spend heavily on getting out every loyal vote, and sometimes on buying a few extra.
The tariff and the currency
Two economic issues dominated debate. The first was the protective tariff, a tax on imported goods. Republicans defended high tariffs as the shield that protected American industry and the wages of American workers. Democrats, especially in the agricultural South, argued that tariffs raised the price of everything farmers bought while doing nothing for the crops they sold on world markets. The McKinley Tariff of 1890 pushed average rates on dutiable goods to about half their value. Cleveland had made tariff reduction the centerpiece of his annual message to Congress in 1887, a rare case of a Gilded Age president staking his career on an economic argument. He lost the next election, though historians disagree about how much the tariff fight cost him.
The second issue was money. During the Civil War the government had printed paper money, called greenbacks, not backed by gold. Afterward, creditors and many economists wanted a return to gold, while debtors wanted more money in circulation. The Coinage Act of 1873 ended the minting of silver dollars, a step its critics called "the Crime of '73." As the economy grew faster than the supply of gold, prices fell for decades. Deflation helped those who were owed money and hurt those who owed it, because every dollar borrowed had to be repaid in dollars worth more. Compromise laws in 1878 and 1890 required some silver purchases, but the fight was far from over.
Reformers inside the system
Some reformers came from within the parties. A group of mostly well-educated, Northeastern Republicans believed that honest government mattered more than party loyalty. When they abandoned the Republican candidate James G. Blaine in 1884 and backed Democrat Grover Cleveland, they were nicknamed Mugwumps. Blaine had been tied to a railroad bond scandal by letters in which he had written, embarrassingly, to burn the letter. Their critics joked that a mugwump sat on the fence with his mug on one side and his wump on the other.
Reformers also attacked the spoils system, under which winning parties handed government jobs to loyal party workers. Their success in creating a merit-based civil service for part of the federal workforce was real but limited, and parties found new sources of money in corporate contributions. Meanwhile city politics was run by machines that traded jobs, favors and help for votes, especially among immigrants who had nowhere else to turn.
Worked example: the election of 1884
The 1884 race shows how small things decided national outcomes. Cleveland, the reforming governor of New York, faced Blaine, the most popular Republican of his day. Both sides traded personal attacks: Republicans revealed that Cleveland had probably fathered a child outside marriage, and Democrats circulated the Blaine letters. The election came down to New York.
Days before the vote, a Protestant minister speaking at a meeting Blaine attended described the Democrats as the party of "Rum, Romanism, and Rebellion," an insult to Irish Catholic voters. Blaine failed to rebuke him quickly, and Democrats spread the phrase across the city. Cleveland carried New York by roughly 1,100 votes out of more than a million cast, and with it the presidency. No one can prove that the remark tipped the state, since rain upstate, Mugwump defections and a third-party temperance candidate also cut Blaine's vote. But the case shows how a politics of identity, religion and loyalty could decide an election while the questions of industrial power, labor and farm debt were barely discussed. Americans who wanted those questions answered would increasingly look outside the two parties.
