Skip to main content

Carthage was destroyed, but arguments about it never stopped. Some concern what Carthaginians actually did. Others concern how their enemies described them, and how later peoples have claimed them as ancestors. Each is a lesson in reading evidence when one side's voice is mostly missing.

The accusation

Greek and Roman writers accused the Carthaginians of sacrificing children to their gods. Diodorus wrote that when an invading Greek army threatened Carthage in 310 BCE, its leaders sacrificed two hundred children of noble families to win back divine favor. The Hebrew Bible condemns similar rites among its own neighbors and names a place in the valley outside Jerusalem where children were "passed through the fire": the Tophet. Modern scholars borrowed the biblical word tophet for the open-air sanctuaries where Carthaginians and other western Phoenicians buried burned remains.

What the ground holds

The tophet of Carthage was discovered in 1921. Over the centuries it had received a vast number of burials, often estimated in the tens of thousands. The urns held the burned bones of infants and very young children, and sometimes of lambs or young goats, many marked by carved stones. The stones carry dedications to Baal Hammon and Tanit, often ending with a formula saying that the god heard the giver's voice and blessed them, which is the language of a vow being fulfilled. Similar sanctuaries have been found in Sicily and Sardinia.

Two readings

One group of scholars argues that the tophets were special cemeteries for infants who died of natural causes, perhaps stillborn or very young babies who were not buried with adults. They point out that infant death rates in the ancient world were very high, that some remains seem to be from babies who died before or around birth, and that Greek and Roman writers had every reason to blacken an enemy.

Others answer that natural deaths would not explain the vow inscriptions, the animal substitutes or the specific Greek, Roman and biblical testimony, and that some studies of the bones show many children of the same narrow age, which fits a rite better than a pattern of disease. On present evidence, most specialists think child sacrifice did take place, while they continue to debate how often and why. It may have been a rare, extreme vow by leading families, not a routine practice. Honest history has to hold that conclusion even though it is painful, and it should apply the same standard to every ancient society, including those that left infants to die of exposure.

Written by the victors

The Romans turned Carthage into a symbol of treachery. The Roman phrase "Punic faith" meant bad faith or treachery, though Rome's own conduct before the Third Punic War hardly shows the Romans as models of good faith. Roman authors described Carthaginians as cruel, greedy and cunning, and these stereotypes were repeated for two thousand years.

Some Roman sources preserve more than prejudice. The comedy Poenulus by Plautus, from the early second century BCE, contains lines spoken in the Punic language by a Carthaginian merchant. The play mocks him as a foreigner, yet it also shows him as a loving father searching for his lost daughters, and its Punic lines are precious evidence for the spoken language.

Life after destruction

The site did not stay empty. After a failed Roman colony in 122 BCE, Julius Caesar planned a new colony, and under Augustus Carthage was refounded as a Roman city. It grew into one of the largest cities of the western empire and a major center of early Christianity. The Punic language lasted far longer still. Around 400 CE, the bishop Augustine noted that country people near his town, when asked what they were, still answered "Canaanites", more than five centuries after Carthage fell.

Modern claimants

Modern nations have also reached back to the Phoenicians. In the twentieth century some Lebanese writers, especially among Christian communities, stressed a Phoenician heritage to define a Lebanese identity separate from Arab nationalism; others answered that this ignored centuries of shared Arab history. Tunisia treats Carthage and Hannibal as part of its national story. Claims like these say more about present needs than about ancient genealogy.

Worked example: testing Diodorus

Suppose you must decide how far to trust Diodorus on the sacrifice of 310 BCE. Start with the source. Diodorus wrote nearly three centuries later, in Greek, drawing on earlier Greek historians of Sicily who were Carthage's enemies. That is a reason for caution, not dismissal.

Next, look for independent evidence. The tophet's vow inscriptions were written by Carthaginians themselves and speak of gifts to the gods. The burned remains of infants and animals fit a rite of offering. Bone studies are disputed, but several point to deliberate selection by age. Taken together, the evidence suggests that Diodorus was describing a real practice, even if his specific number and story cannot be checked.

Finally, weigh the motive to exaggerate. Hostile writers may well have made the practice sound more common and more cruel than it was. A careful conclusion keeps all three findings at once: a real rite, a hostile tradition, and an uncertain scale. That is a fair way to judge any people whose own books have been lost, and a reminder that the dignity of the children in those urns is honored by telling the truth about them, not by hiding it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. According to Diodorus, what did Carthage's leaders do in 310 BCE?
2. Where does the word tophet for these sanctuaries come from?
3. What did the urns in the tophet of Carthage hold?
4. What do scholars who doubt the sacrifice claims think the tophets were?
5. What do most specialists now think about child sacrifice at Carthage?
6. What did the Roman phrase "Punic faith" mean?
7. Why is the comedy Poenulus by Plautus valuable to historians?
8. According to Augustine, what did country people in North Africa still call themselves around 400 CE?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia