Of all the western settlements, one outgrew the rest and eventually outgrew Tyre itself. Its name in Phoenician was Qart-hadasht, and for six centuries it was among the richest cities of the Mediterranean.
A queen and an ox hide
The name Qart-hadasht means "new city." It stood on a peninsula in the Gulf of Tunis, near where the Mediterranean narrows between Africa and Sicily, an ideal position to control sea traffic between east and west. Greek and Roman writers told a founding story. A princess of Tyre named Elissa, whom the Romans called Dido, fled after her brother, King Pygmalion, murdered her husband. Landing in Africa, she asked the local ruler for as much land as an ox hide could cover. She cut the hide into thin strips and used them to surround a whole hill, the Byrsa, which became the city's citadel.
Ancient writers dated the founding to 814 BCE. The ox hide tale is a legend, and it may have grown from a Greek pun, since byrsa is Greek for hide. The oldest archaeological finds at Carthage date to the late ninth or the eighth century BCE, close enough to the traditional date to suggest it is not far wrong.
From colony to leader
By the sixth century BCE it had become the leader of the western Phoenicians, partly because Tyre was weakened by its wars with the empires, and partly because the western settlements needed protection from Greek colonists pressing into Sicily, Spain and southern France. Carthage built a network of alliances and dependencies stretching across western Sicily, Sardinia, Ibiza, the coast of North Africa and southern Spain.
Carthage also made treaties. The Greek historian Polybius saw a bronze copy of a treaty between Carthage and Rome that he dated to the very first year of the Roman Republic, traditionally 509 BCE. For centuries the two cities were partners, not enemies.
The real rivals were the Greeks of Sicily. In 480 BCE a large Carthaginian army landed at Himera on the north coast of the island, and Gelon, the ruler of Syracuse, defeated the Carthaginians at Himera. Wars over Sicily went on, with victories and defeats on both sides, for more than two hundred years.
A government Aristotle admired
Greek writers spoke of Carthaginian kings, and scholars still debate what powers early rulers held. By the third century BCE, and probably well before, the city was led by two suffetes, chief magistrates elected each year; the title comes from the same root as the Hebrew word for judge. A council of elders, drawn from the leading families, handled war, peace and foreign policy. A powerful court known as the Hundred and Four judged generals after their campaigns, and failed commanders could be punished savagely, sometimes by crucifixion. A popular assembly of citizens decided matters when the suffetes and the council disagreed.
The philosopher Aristotle, writing in the fourth century BCE, counted Carthage among the best governed states he knew. He noted that it had never suffered a serious revolt by its people or fallen under a tyrant. But he also made a sharp criticism: Aristotle warned that wealth counted too heavily in choosing Carthage's officials, so that high office could in effect be bought, and he feared this would teach citizens to value money above merit.
Farms, harbors and soldiers
Carthage was a trading city, but it was also a farming power. Wealthy Carthaginians owned large estates in the fertile lands of what is now northern Tunisia, worked by Libyan farmers and slaves, and the Libyan villages paid heavy taxes in grain. A Carthaginian named Mago wrote a famous treatise on farming in twenty-eight books, and after Rome destroyed the city, the Roman Senate ordered Mago's farming manual to be translated into Latin.
The city's harbors impressed every visitor. Ships passed through a rectangular merchant harbor into a circular naval harbor with an island in the middle, with covered sheds for well over a hundred warships. The army worked differently. Carthage had relatively few citizen soldiers and relied heavily on paid and allied troops: Libyan infantry, Numidian horsemen, Iberian and Celtic warriors and slingers from the Balearic Islands. These forces were skilled and flexible, but their loyalty depended on pay, a weakness that would come back to haunt the city.
Worked example: weighing Aristotle's verdict
Aristotle's praise is valuable precisely because he was an outsider who disliked much about non-Greek peoples, yet he placed Carthage beside the most admired Greek constitutions. He saw in it a mixture of three elements: something like kingship in the suffetes, aristocracy in the council and democracy in the assembly. Mixing them, he thought, kept any one group from dominating.
His criticism points to a real tension. A state that rewards wealth may attract talented leaders who have proved themselves in business, but it may also shut out poorer citizens and turn public office into an investment. Later, the historian Polybius applied the same framework to explain Carthage's defeat by Rome, arguing that by his own time the Carthaginian people had gained too much power while the Roman Senate still led. Historians today treat both verdicts with care: they are analyses written by Greeks using Greek categories, and they tell us as much about Greek political theory as about how Carthage really worked. Still, they show that ancient observers saw Carthage not as a barbarian tyranny but as a serious republic.
