In 1937 the Muslim League looked like a fading party of notables. Ten years later it governed a new country. The decade between turned on two things: elections under a new constitution, and a world war that changed what Britain could do and what Indians would accept.
The elections of 1937
The Government of India Act of 1935 gave the provinces elected ministries with real powers, while Britain kept control at the center. The first elections, held early in 1937, were a triumph for the Congress, which formed ministries in seven of the eleven provinces and later an eighth. They were a humiliation for the League. The Muslim League won fewer than a quarter of the seats reserved for Muslims. In the two great Muslim majority provinces it barely registered. Punjab was won by the Unionist Party, an alliance of Muslim, Hindu and Sikh landholders and farmers led by Sikander Hayat Khan, and Bengal by Fazlul Huq's Krishak Praja Party, which spoke for tenant farmers.
Congress rule in the provinces lasted two years. League leaders accused the ministries of favoring Hindus, citing the singing of the patriotic song "Bande Mataram" in assemblies and new school schemes. Congress replied that the charges were exaggerated. What mattered politically was that many Muslims came to believe them.
War and the Lahore Resolution
In September 1939 the Viceroy, Lord Linlithgow, announced that India was at war with Germany. Congress ministries resigned because the Viceroy had declared India at war without consulting Indian leaders. Jinnah asked Muslims to mark the resignations as a "Day of Deliverance". With Congress out of office, Britain needed the League's cooperation, and the League's standing rose.
In March 1940, at Lahore, Jinnah argued that Hindus and Muslims were two nations with different religions, laws, heroes and histories, and the League adopted a resolution calling for the grouping of Muslim majority areas in the northwest and east. It did not use the word Pakistan, but newspapers did at once, and the name stuck. The resolution was vague about borders, about the center and about the millions of Muslims who lived elsewhere. That vagueness was useful: different Muslims could read their own hopes into it.
Cripps and Quit India
In 1942, with Japan advancing toward India, Britain sent the cabinet minister Stafford Cripps with an offer: full dominion status after the war and a body to write a constitution. One clause mattered more than the rest. The Cripps offer let any province opt out of the new Indian union, a first official hint that India might not stay whole. Congress rejected the offer.
In August 1942 Congress launched the Quit India movement demanding an immediate British departure. The government arrested Gandhi, Nehru and the whole leadership within hours, and most stayed in prison until 1945. With Congress leaders in prison, the League expanded its organization, recruited members by the hundreds of thousands and took part in ministries in Bengal, Sind and the Frontier.
Simla and the elections of 1945 to 1946
As the war ended, the Viceroy, Lord Wavell, called leaders to Simla in June 1945 to form an all-Indian executive council. The Simla Conference broke down when Jinnah insisted that the League alone should nominate the Muslim members, a claim Congress, which had Muslim leaders of its own, would not accept.
New elections in the winter of 1945 to 1946 settled the question of who spoke for Muslims. Campaigning on the single word Pakistan, with help from student volunteers and rural religious leaders, the League won every seat reserved for Muslims in the central assembly and the great majority in the provinces. Congress swept the general seats. India now had two parties, each with a clear mandate from its own voters and each refusing the other's terms.
Britain, meanwhile, was exhausted. A Labour government took office in July 1945 committed to Indian self-rule. Public fury greeted the trials at Delhi's Red Fort of officers of the Indian National Army, which had fought alongside Japan; the first three defendants were a Hindu, a Muslim and a Sikh. In February 1946 sailors of the Royal Indian Navy mutinied in Bombay. British officials increasingly doubted that Indian soldiers and police would keep them in power.
Worked example: the coalition that never was
After the 1937 elections, League leaders in the United Provinces expected to share power with Congress, as the two had cooperated in the campaign. Congress had won a clear majority on its own. It offered places in the ministry only if League members joined the Congress party and dissolved their separate group in the assembly. The League refused.
Some historians treat this as a turning point: a generous coalition might have kept the League inside a common nationalism. Others answer that Congress, with a majority and Muslim members of its own, had no duty to share power with a party that had won few seats, and that the League's later rise owed far more to the war. Applying this level's ideas, the case shows how a decision that looked sensible in 1937 could feed a story of exclusion that the 1945 to 1946 campaign then turned into votes. Political choices are judged by the information leaders had, but their consequences run on the memories of voters.
