Skip to main content

Before anyone could divide India, people had to argue about what India was. Was it one nation with many faiths, or several nations sharing a territory? Was religion a private matter, a culture, or the basis of a people's political rights? The answers given between the 1870s and the 1940s did not make Partition inevitable, but they supplied the language in which it was demanded and resisted.

Syed Ahmad Khan and Muslim anxiety

After the revolt of 1857 many north Indian Muslims, once the ruling class of the Mughal world, found themselves distrusted by the British and outpaced in English education by Hindus. The reformer Syed Ahmad Khan founded a college at Aligarh in 1875 to give Muslims modern learning within their faith. In the 1880s he went further. Syed Ahmad Khan urged Muslims to stay out of the Congress, fearing that elected councils would mean rule by the Hindu majority. He sometimes spoke of Hindus and Muslims as distinct qaums, a word that can mean community or nation. His admirers see a realist protecting a weak minority; critics see the seed of a politics of separation.

Language sharpened the divide. In the north, the spoken tongue was much the same for everyone, but Urdu was written in Persian script and Hindi in Devanagari. In 1900 the government of the North-Western Provinces allowed Hindi in Devanagari script to be used in the courts alongside Urdu, and Muslim leaders protested. Script became a badge of community.

Iqbal and the north-west

The poet and philosopher Muhammad Iqbal gave the presidential address to the Muslim League at Allahabad in December 1930. He argued that Islam was a social order as well as a faith and that Indian Muslims needed space to live by it. Iqbal called for a consolidated Muslim state in the northwest, joining Punjab, the North-West Frontier Province, Sind and Baluchistan, possibly within the British Empire. Bengal was not in his scheme.

Three years later a Cambridge student, Choudhry Rahmat Ali, issued a pamphlet called Now or Never. It gave the idea a name: Pakstan, built from the letters of Punjab, Afghania, Kashmir, Sind and Baluchistan. The word also suggests "land of the pure" in Urdu and Persian. Senior Muslim politicians dismissed the scheme as a student's fantasy at the time.

Hindu nationalism

A parallel current arose among Hindus. The Hindu Mahasabha was formed in 1915, and the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, or RSS, a disciplined volunteer movement, was founded at Nagpur in 1925. Their leading thinker, V. D. Savarkar, wrote Hindutva in 1923. Savarkar defined a Hindu as someone who regards India as both fatherland and holy land. By that test, Muslims and Christians, whose holy places lay abroad, could live in India but never fully belong to the nation in the same way. In 1937, as president of the Mahasabha, Savarkar said openly that India held two nations. The two-nation idea, in other words, had defenders on both sides.

Composite nationalism

The Congress answer was that India was one nation in which religion should not decide citizenship. Jawaharlal Nehru thought religious politics a distraction from poverty and land. The most important Muslim voice for this view was Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, an Islamic scholar and Congress president from 1940 to 1946, who opposed Partition to the end. He argued that Muslims scattered across India would only be weakened by a state that left millions of them behind.

Many devout Muslims agreed. The Jamiat Ulama-i-Hind, led by Husain Ahmad Madani, defended composite nationalism: Muslims and Hindus could form one nation by shared homeland while keeping separate faiths. The Pashtun Khudai Khidmatgars, Punjab's Unionists and others also opposed the League. Pakistan was never the only Muslim position.

B. R. Ambedkar, the leader of the untouchables, approached the question as a hard-headed analyst. In Thoughts on Pakistan (1940) he examined the case on both sides and concluded that if Muslims were truly determined on Pakistan, forcing them to stay in an unwilling union would weaken India. He also raised the uncomfortable question of what would happen to minorities on the wrong side of any line.

Worked example: reading Iqbal backward

Pakistan honors Iqbal as its spiritual founder, and his Allahabad address is often quoted as the first blueprint of the country. Read it in its own time and the picture is less tidy. Iqbal asked for a Muslim unit in the northwest, not for the eastern districts that would later make up most of Pakistan's population. He left open whether it would be inside a federal India or the Empire. In letters to Jinnah in 1937 he pressed for Muslim provinces with real power, but he died in 1938, two years before the League adopted a separation resolution.

The lesson applies well beyond Iqbal. Historians call it teleology to read a past idea as if it were heading toward the outcome we know. Iqbal, Rahmat Ali, Savarkar and Azad were arguing about many possible futures: loose federations, autonomous provinces, protected minorities, a single secular nation. Asking what each thinker actually proposed, and to whom, keeps those other paths in view and makes the final choice of 1947 look like what it was: a choice.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Why did Syed Ahmad Khan urge Muslims to stay out of the Congress?
2. What did Iqbal call for in his Allahabad address of 1930?
3. Where did the name Pakstan, coined in 1933, come from?
4. How did Savarkar's Hindutva define a Hindu?
5. Which Congress president from 1940 to 1946 opposed Partition to the end?
6. What did the Jamiat Ulama-i-Hind under Husain Ahmad Madani defend?
7. What did Ambedkar conclude in Thoughts on Pakistan (1940)?
8. What did the North-Western Provinces government allow in 1900?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia