Napoleon's armies could defeat any king's army in a day. They struggled against peoples who refused to accept defeat. In two places especially, the French colony of Saint-Domingue in the Caribbean and the kingdom of Spain, popular resistance cost him armies, money and prestige, and showed that power resting on force alone has limits.
Saint-Domingue and the return of slavery
The revolution had abolished slavery in 1794, and in Saint-Domingue, France's richest colony, the former slave Toussaint Louverture had become its effective ruler. In 1801 he issued a constitution that made him governor for life while still recognizing French sovereignty. Bonaparte saw this as defiance. At the end of 1801 he sent an expedition of more than twenty thousand troops under his brother-in-law, General Charles Leclerc, to restore French authority. Secret instructions told Leclerc to disarm and remove the Black leadership.
In June 1802 Toussaint was invited to a meeting, seized and shipped to France. He is reported to have said on board that in overthrowing him they had cut down only the trunk of the tree of liberty, which would grow again from its roots. He died in April 1803 in a cold cell at Fort de Joux, in the Jura mountains. A law of May 1802 had meanwhile confirmed slavery in colonies where it had never been ended, and in July slavery was restored in Guadeloupe. When this news reached Saint-Domingue, Black officers who had joined the French, including Jean-Jacques Dessalines and Henri Christophe, changed sides again.
Disease destroyed the expedition. Yellow fever killed French soldiers by the tens of thousands, Leclerc among them in November 1802. His successor, Rochambeau, waged a war of terror that only hardened resistance. After defeat at Vertières in November 1803 the French withdrew, and on 1 January 1804 Dessalines declared the independence of Haiti. Without Saint-Domingue, Napoleon had little use for French Louisiana, and in 1803 he sold it to the United States, roughly doubling that country's size.
The trap at Bayonne
Spain was France's ally, but a weak one, ruled by the unpopular Charles IV and his favorite minister, Manuel Godoy. In 1807 French troops crossed Spain to invade Portugal, and more kept coming. In March 1808 a riot at Aranjuez forced Charles to abdicate in favor of his son Ferdinand. Napoleon summoned both to Bayonne, just across the French border, and pressured each to give up his rights. He then made his brother Joseph king of Spain.
Madrid had already risen. On 2 May 1808, the Dos de Mayo, crowds in the capital attacked French troops, and Marshal Murat crushed the rising and had prisoners shot. Revolt spread across the country, organized by local juntas, or committees. In July a French army of about eighteen thousand men surrendered at Bailén, in Andalusia, the first time a large Napoleonic army had capitulated in the field.
The little war
Napoleon came in person in late 1808 with a huge army and retook Madrid, but he could not hold the country. Bands of irregular fighters ambushed convoys, killed couriers and stragglers, and vanished into the hills. The Spanish called this the guerrilla, meaning "little war," and the word entered every European language. Cities resisted too: Saragossa endured two sieges, and thousands of its people died before it fell in 1809. Both sides committed atrocities against prisoners and civilians.
A British army under Arthur Wellesley, later Duke of Wellington, fought alongside Portuguese and Spanish forces. Behind the fortified Lines of Torres Vedras outside Lisbon it survived a French offensive in 1810, and it drove the French from Spain after victory at Vitoria in June 1813. Napoleon kept a quarter of a million troops or more in Iberia for years, and later accounts have him calling the war his "Spanish ulcer."
The Constitution of Cádiz
Resistance produced its own political revolution. Meeting in the besieged port of Cádiz, a parliament, the Cortes, drew up the Constitution of 1812, which declared that sovereignty resides in the nation. It created a constitutional monarchy, near-universal male suffrage through indirect elections and freedom of the press, though it kept Catholicism as the only permitted religion. Its supporters called themselves liberales, which gave European politics the word "liberal." When Ferdinand VII returned in 1814 he abolished the constitution and imprisoned many of its authors.
Worked example: what were people fighting for?
Compare a soldier in Dessalines's army in 1803 with a Spanish guerrilla in 1810. The Haitian fought against re-enslavement: for him, French victory meant being returned to the status of property. His cause was liberty in the most literal sense, and it was the revolution's own principle turned against the revolution's heir. The Spaniard might fight for king and church, for revenge on soldiers who had looted his village, or for the new constitution. Many fought for all three.
Both struggles show that resistance rooted in daily life can outlast a far stronger army. They also show that a regime claiming to bring liberty at bayonet point invites the question of whose liberty it means. Napoleon offered Spaniards a reforming king and a modern code. Many preferred a backward king of their own to a progressive one imposed by an invader, and few Haitians could believe in French liberty once French ships brought back the chains.
