Skip to main content

In 1914 nearly every Arabic-speaking land east of Egypt was governed from Istanbul, as it had been for four centuries. Provinces such as Damascus, Aleppo, Beirut, Baghdad, Basra and Mosul were administrative units of one empire, not separate countries. When the Ottoman Empire entered the First World War on Germany's side late in 1914, Britain and France began planning for its defeat. Over the next four years Britain made three different commitments about the same lands to three different audiences. Much of the modern Middle East grew out of the gaps between them.

The promise to the Sharif

Hussein ibn Ali, the Sharif of Mecca, guarded Islam's holiest cities on the sultan's behalf. In letters exchanged in 1915 and 1916, known as the Hussein-McMahon correspondence, Sir Henry McMahon, Britain's High Commissioner in Egypt, offered British recognition of Arab independence across a wide area if Hussein rose against the Ottomans. McMahon excluded "portions of Syria lying to the west of the districts of Damascus, Homs, Hama and Aleppo," along with places where French interests were at stake. Whether that exclusion covered Palestine became one of the longest quarrels of the century: Arab leaders said it did not, and British officials later insisted it did. Hussein launched the Arab Revolt in June 1916. His son Faisal led its forces north with British gold, arms and advisers, among them T. E. Lawrence, and Arab troops entered Damascus alongside British forces in October 1918.

The bargain between allies

At the same time two diplomats, Mark Sykes for Britain and François Georges-Picot for France, worked out a secret plan in 1916, with Russia's consent, for dividing the Ottoman Arab lands into zones. Palestine was to be placed under an international administration. The world learned of it when the Bolsheviks published the Sykes-Picot Agreement in late 1917, after seizing power in Russia, to expose the secret diplomacy of the old regime. Arab leaders felt betrayed. Historians point out that the borders finally drawn differed from the 1916 lines in important ways: Mosul, for example, went to British Iraq rather than to France. Yet the agreement became, and remains, a symbol of outsiders carving up the region over the heads of the people who lived there.

The declaration to the Zionists

The third commitment was the Balfour Declaration of November 2, 1917, a letter from Foreign Secretary Arthur Balfour to Lord Rothschild, a leader of the British Jewish community. It stated that the government viewed "with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people," and added the condition that "nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine." Those communities, Muslim and Christian Arabs, made up roughly nine tenths of the population. British motives were mixed: genuine sympathy for Zionism among some ministers, hope of rallying Jewish opinion in Russia and the United States behind the war, and a wish for a friendly presence near the Suez Canal. Zionists saw a great power recognizing a scattered people's claim to its ancient homeland. Palestinian Arabs saw a foreign government promising their country to others without asking them.

Peace without consent

At the Paris Peace Conference of 1919 Faisal pleaded for Arab independence. President Woodrow Wilson, who had spoken of self-government for the peoples of the Ottoman Empire, sent an American team, the King-Crane Commission, to ask local people what they wanted. It reported that most people it heard opposed French rule and the Zionist program and preferred a united, independent Syria, with American help if outside help was needed. Britain and France ignored the report, which was not published until 1922. At the San Remo conference of April 1920 the Allies gave Syria and Lebanon to France and Iraq and Palestine to Britain as mandates. The League of Nations described such territories as peoples "not yet able to stand by themselves," to be guided by an advanced nation until they could. Supporters of the system saw a step beyond outright annexation, with reports to an international body. Many Arabs saw colonial rule under a new name.

Worked example: a kingdom in Damascus

In March 1920 a Syrian Congress meeting in Damascus declared Faisal king of an independent Syria. The congress included Muslims, Christians and Jews, and it began drafting a constitution with an elected parliament and protections for minorities. France refused to recognize it. In July 1920 a French army under General Henri Gouraud defeated a small, poorly armed Syrian force at Maysalun, where the Syrian war minister, Yusuf al-Azma, was killed, and French troops occupied Damascus. Faisal was sent into exile.

Apply the level's ideas. The wartime promise to Hussein pointed toward Arab independence. The bargain between allies had marked this territory for France. The peace process heard what local people wanted and then overrode it. The following year Britain made Faisal king of Iraq instead, a reminder that the new map was being drawn by whoever held the armies. For many Syrians, Maysalun became a lasting symbol: a homegrown experiment in constitutional self-rule ended by a foreign power within months of its birth.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did McMahon offer Sharif Hussein in his letters of 1915 and 1916?
2. When did Sharif Hussein launch the Arab Revolt?
3. How did the Sykes-Picot Agreement become public?
4. What did the Balfour Declaration say the British government viewed with favour?
5. What condition did the Balfour Declaration attach to its promise?
6. Roughly what share of Palestine's people belonged to non-Jewish communities in 1917?
7. What did the King-Crane Commission report in 1919?
8. What did the San Remo conference of April 1920 decide?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia