By 1428 the Dauphin Charles looked close to defeat. English and Burgundian forces held northern France, including Paris and Reims, the city where French kings were traditionally crowned. Charles, uncrowned and mocked as the "king of Bourges" after the city where he often held court, governed the lands south of the Loire. In October 1428 an English army besieged Orléans. The city was a key crossing on the river Loire, the gateway to the Dauphin's remaining territory. If it fell, the road south would lie open.
A girl from the borderlands
Into this crisis came Joan, a peasant girl of about seventeen from the village of Domrémy, on the eastern edge of France near Lorraine. She said that since childhood she had heard the voices of saints, Saint Michael, Saint Catherine and Saint Margaret, and that they told her to drive out the English and bring the Dauphin to be crowned. She persuaded a local captain to give her an escort, cut her hair short, wore men's clothing for the journey, and reached the Dauphin's court at Chinon early in 1429.
Charles was cautious. He sent her to Poitiers to be questioned by churchmen, partly to make sure she was not a witch or a fraud. The theologians found nothing wrong in her and advised that she be tested by letting her join the relief of Orléans. That was enough.
Orléans and Patay
Joan arrived at Orléans with supplies in late April 1429. The English had built a ring of forts but not a complete blockade. Over the following days the French attacked these forts with new energy, Joan at the front with her banner, and she was wounded by an arrow. On 8 May the English abandoned the siege. The siege was lifted in May 1429, after more than six months.
The French followed up quickly. In June they took a string of Loire towns and caught an English army at Patay before its archers could plant their stakes. The famous English commander John Talbot was captured. For once, an English army had been destroyed in open battle.
Crowning a king
Joan then insisted on a march through enemy territory to Reims. On 17 July 1429 Charles was crowned and anointed in Reims cathedral. The ceremony mattered because anointing at Reims, by long tradition, made a man truly king in the eyes of most French people. Henry VI, though proclaimed king of France, had not been crowned there, and never would be.
Capture and trial
After Reims, Joan's fortunes turned. An attack on Paris in September 1429 failed, and she was wounded again. In May 1430, defending the town of Compiègne, she was captured by Burgundian forces. The Burgundians sold her to the English for ten thousand livres. Charles VII, now king, made no effective attempt to rescue or ransom her.
The English wanted her condemned by the Church, which would show that Charles had been crowned with the help of a heretic. The trial was held at Rouen in 1431 under Pierre Cauchon, bishop of Beauvais, a firm supporter of the English cause. Joan faced weeks of questioning by learned men. In May, under threat of burning, she signed an abjuration. Days later she was found again in men's clothing, declared a relapsed heretic, and burned in the marketplace of Rouen on 30 May 1431. She was about nineteen.
Afterlife
Once Charles VII had recovered Rouen, he ordered an inquiry. With the pope's approval, a nullification trial in 1456 overturned her conviction. The Catholic Church canonized her as a saint in 1920. Historians still debate her military role. Some stress that experienced captains such as Jean de Dunois led the fighting and that the English were already overstretched. Others argue that her confidence transformed French morale at exactly the right moment. Both views can be partly true.
Worked example: a trial built to convict
The records of Joan's trial survive in detail, so the voice of a peasant woman of the fifteenth century speaks from them, which is very rare. They also show how a legal process can be shaped toward a fixed result.
Look at the procedure. Joan had no lawyer to advise her. Although tried by a church court, she was kept in a military prison guarded by English soldiers, not in a church prison with women attendants, as church practice required. Her judges were chosen largely from supporters of the English. Questions were framed as traps. Asked whether she knew she was in God's grace, she faced a dilemma: saying yes would sound presumptuous, saying no would admit guilt. She answered, in substance, that if she was not in grace she prayed God would bring her to it, and if she was, she prayed God would keep her there. Her judges were reportedly stunned.
The case shows why ideas such as the right to counsel, impartial judges and protection from coercion matter. A trial can follow all the outward forms of law and still be designed to reach a verdict decided in advance. The nullification judges of 1456 made exactly that point when they condemned the earlier process.
