By convention the Hundred Years' War ran from 1337 to 1453, but its roots reach back to 1066, when William, Duke of Normandy, conquered England. From then on the kings of England were also great lords in France. Under Henry II in the twelfth century, the lands of the Angevin family stretched from the Scottish border to the Pyrenees. King John lost Normandy to Philip II of France in 1204, and by the early fourteenth century the English crown kept only one large piece of that old inheritance: the duchy of Aquitaine, usually called Gascony, in the southwest, centered on the port of Bordeaux.
A duchy with strings attached
Gascony mattered. Its vineyards shipped enormous quantities of wine to England, and the customs paid on that trade helped fill the English treasury. But feudal law built a trap into the arrangement. For Gascony, the king of England was a vassal of the king of France. He had to perform homage, kneeling as a sworn man of the French king, and Gascon subjects could appeal over their duke's head to the royal court in Paris, the Parlement. Every appeal gave Paris a lever inside Bordeaux. Short wars over the duchy in 1294 and 1324 had already shown how fragile this was.
The succession crisis of 1328
Then came a dynastic accident. Philip IV of France had three sons. Each became king in turn, and each died without a surviving son. When the last of them, Charles IV, died in 1328, the nearest relative through the male line was his cousin, Philip of Valois, who was crowned as Philip VI. Yet Philip IV had also had a daughter, Isabella, who married Edward II of England. Her son, the young Edward III, was the dead king's nephew and so a closer blood relative than Philip. Edward's claim came through his mother, Isabella.
French lawyers and nobles held that a woman could not wear the crown and could not pass on a right she did not have herself. Decades later, French writers gave this principle an ancient pedigree by citing the Salic law, an old Frankish law code, even though that code had dealt with inheriting land, not kingdoms. In 1328 the reasons were more practical. The great nobles of France preferred an adult French prince to a fifteen year old English king whose government was run by his mother and her ally Roger Mortimer.
From grievance to war
Edward at first accepted the result. In 1329 he did homage to Philip VI at Amiens, and in 1331 he conceded that it had been liege homage, the most binding kind. But other quarrels piled up. France had been allied with Scotland since 1295, a pact later called the Auld Alliance, and Philip gave refuge to the young Scottish king David II while Edward backed a rival. Edward in turn sheltered Robert of Artois, a French noble Philip had banished. In the Low Countries, the great cloth towns of Flanders depended on English wool to keep their looms working, which gave Edward economic leverage over a region that legally owed loyalty to France.
In May 1337 Philip declared Gascony confiscated, the standard punishment for a disobedient vassal. That act is the conventional start of the war. In January 1340, at Ghent, Edward went further and formally took the title King of France. Historians still argue about how seriously he meant it. Some see the claim as a bargaining chip, raised to win Gascony in full sovereignty, free of homage. Others think Edward, and later Henry V, genuinely wanted the French throne. Either way the title had a practical use: Flemish towns could ally with Edward as the "true" French king without technically becoming rebels.
Not one war
The name is misleading in two ways. First, the conflict was a series of wars broken by long truces, stretching over 116 years by the usual dates, and some decades saw little fighting at all. Second, it was never simply England against France. Scots, Flemings, Castilians, Bretons, Navarrese and, above all, Burgundians took part, usually for their own reasons. Many lords who spoke French fought for the English king, and Gascons on the whole preferred a distant English duke to a nearby French master. Feelings of national belonging grew during the war; they did not cause it.
Worked example: one ceremony, two meanings
Picture Amiens cathedral in June 1329. Edward, aged sixteen, has crossed the Channel to kneel before the man who took the crown he believed was his. The French chancellor asks him to do liege homage, which would bind him to serve Philip against all others. Edward's advisers answer that he will do homage in the way his ancestors did and will check the records once he gets home. Philip accepts the vague form, and the ceremony goes ahead.
Each side left with a different understanding. For Philip, the ritual confirmed that the English king was his man and that Gascony lay inside the French kingdom, under French courts. For Edward's council, it was the price of keeping the duchy and avoiding a war they could not yet afford. Two years later Edward admitted in writing that the homage was liege, but resentment remained on both sides.
The case shows why the war was so hard to end. Feudal homage worked tolerably well when a lord was far more powerful than his vassal. It broke down when the vassal was himself a crowned king with his own army, treasury and parliament. Any peace would have to answer a question no ceremony could settle: could one sovereign ruler also be another ruler's subject? The long search for an answer, through battles, truces and marriages, is the story of the next century.
