Conquest with many hands
The Spanish conquests of the Mexica empire between 1519 and 1521 and of the Inca empire from 1532 are often told as tales of a few hundred bold Spaniards defeating millions. Historians today tell them differently. Indigenous allies did much of the fighting, above all the Tlaxcalans, longtime enemies of the Mexica who joined Hernán Cortés in tens of thousands. Epidemics had already struck before the decisive battles. Rival factions inside each empire made alliances with the newcomers for their own reasons. Steel, horses and guns mattered, but the conquests are best understood as wars in which many Indigenous peoples took part, often hoping to come out on top.
A sermon and a law
From the start, some Spaniards asked whether any of this was lawful. A Dominican friar's sermon on Hispaniola in 1511, condemning the settlers' cruelty, so disturbed the colony that both sides appealed to the king. The response was the Laws of Burgos of 1512, the first Spanish code meant to regulate how settlers treated the native peoples of the Indies. It limited working hours, required food and rest and banned some punishments. It also took for granted that native people would work for Spaniards. Enforcement across an ocean was weak.
A document read to the empty air
In 1513 the crown's lawyers produced a strange text called the Requerimiento, the Requirement. It summarized Christian history from Creation to the papacy and explained that the pope had granted these lands to the Spanish monarchs. Conquistadors were ordered to read the Requerimiento aloud, demanding that native peoples accept Spanish rule and allow preaching, before any war could lawfully begin. If they refused, the text warned, war, enslavement and seizure of goods would follow, and the fault would be theirs. It was read in Spanish to people who did not speak it, sometimes from ships or at night outside sleeping villages. Even some Spaniards mocked it. Las Casas later said he did not know whether to laugh or cry at it.
Vitoria's lectures
The deepest challenge came from a university. Francisco de Vitoria, a Dominican theologian at Salamanca, gave a set of lectures on the Indies in 1539. He argued that the native peoples had true dominium, real ownership and political authority, before the Spanish arrived, and that their unbelief did not take it away. He denied that the pope ruled the whole world in worldly matters, so a papal grant could not hand over other peoples' lands. Nor could the emperor claim to be lord of the world.
Vitoria was not a pacifist or an enemy of empire. He accepted some grounds for war, such as a refusal to let Spaniards travel, trade and preach peacefully. Critics then and now note that these grounds could be stretched to justify much of what had already happened. Still, his starting point, that non-Christian peoples held real rights under a law common to all nations, became a foundation stone of international law.
A pope and an emperor
In 1537 Pope Paul III issued the bull Sublimis Deus. It declared that the native peoples of the Americas were true human beings who must not be deprived of their liberty or property, even if they were not Christian, and that they should be converted by preaching and good example. Under pressure from Spain, parts of the pope's related orders were soon withdrawn, but the bull itself was widely cited by reformers.
Then in 1550 something unusual happened. Charles V ordered new conquests in the Americas suspended until learned men had decided how they could be justly carried out. It was the occasion for a formal debate at Valladolid between Bartolomé de las Casas and Juan Ginés de Sepúlveda. The suspension did not last, and conquest went on in practice. But in 1573 new royal ordinances told officials to avoid the word conquest and speak of pacification instead. The language changed more than the reality.
Worked example: reading the Requerimiento
Imagine you are a historian handed the Requerimiento for the first time. How should you read it?
First, ask who it was for. Its supposed audience was the native peoples, but they could not understand it. Its real audience seems to have been Spanish: the king's conscience, his lawyers and the conquistadors who wanted to believe their wars were legal. A document can tell us more about the people who wrote it than about the people it addresses.
Second, ask what it assumes. It treats a papal grant as giving Spain authority over peoples who had never heard of the pope. That is exactly the premise Vitoria rejected a generation later.
Third, notice what its existence admits. No one writes a legal justification unless they think one is needed. The Requerimiento shows a state trying to fit conquest into law, and failing. That tension, between treating people as ends in themselves and using them as means to wealth, ran through the whole age of exploration. The same arguments, about whether every person holds rights simply by being human, would return in later debates over slavery, colonialism and human rights.
