Having rejected their king, the rebel provinces did not at first want to be a republic. They went shopping for a new monarch. Only when every candidate failed did they discover that they could govern themselves, and the system they improvised lasted more than two hundred years.
The search for a sovereign
In 1581 the States General accepted Francis, Duke of Anjou, brother of the French king, as their new lord. He proved unreliable and in 1583 tried to seize Antwerp by force, then left in disgrace. After William's murder the provinces offered sovereignty to Henry III of France and then to Elizabeth I. Both declined, though Elizabeth sent money, troops and the Earl of Leicester as governor general. Leicester quarreled with the States of Holland and returned to England in 1587. From about 1588, the States General and the provincial States held sovereignty themselves. The Republic of the Seven United Netherlands had arrived almost by default.
Seven provinces, one vote each
The Republic had seven voting provinces: Holland, Zeeland, Utrecht, Gelderland, Overijssel, Friesland and Groningen. Drenthe ran its own affairs but had no vote. Territories conquered from Spain in Brabant, Flanders and Limburg were called the Generality Lands, ruled directly by the States General without a vote. Their mostly Catholic inhabitants had fewer rights than citizens of the seven.
The States General met in The Hague. Each province had one vote, however many delegates it sent, and the most important matters, such as war, peace and new taxes, required unanimity. Delegates often had to refer back to their provincial States, which in turn consulted the town councils. Sovereignty, in theory, lay with each province rather than with the union.
Regents, stadholders and pensionaries
Inside each town, power belonged to the regents, patrician families who filled the town councils and often chose their own successors. They were usually merchants or rentiers, not nobles, and they ran the Republic as an oligarchy. Ordinary citizens had no vote, though they could petition, join civic militias and riot when angry.
Two offices balanced the regents. The first was the stadholder. Once the king's deputy in each province, the stadholder became a provincial office usually held by princes of Orange and Nassau, who also served as captain general of the army and admiral of the fleet. The second was the Land's Advocate of Holland, later called the Grand Pensionary, a salaried lawyer who ran Holland's business and often steered the whole union.
Holland dominated because it paid. Under the quota system Holland paid roughly 58 percent of the common budget, more than all the other provinces together. When Holland's leaders disagreed with the stadholder, the Republic faced a crisis, and two camps formed: Orangists, who favored a strong stadholder, and the States party, who defended the regents and provincial rights.
Religion and the fall of Oldenbarnevelt
The first great crisis came during the truce with Spain. Two Leiden theologians, Jacobus Arminius and Franciscus Gomarus, disagreed about predestination. Arminius's followers, called Remonstrants after a petition of 1610, held that people could resist God's grace; their strict Calvinist opponents insisted that God alone chose who would be saved. The dispute became political. Holland's Land's Advocate, Johan van Oldenbarnevelt, sided with toleration for the Remonstrants, while the stadholder Maurice backed their opponents.
Maurice won. In 1618 he purged town councils, and a national church assembly, the Synod of Dort, condemned the Remonstrant teaching on predestination and expelled its ministers. In May 1619 Oldenbarnevelt was beheaded in The Hague after a political trial, aged seventy one. His ally, the jurist Hugo Grotius, was sentenced to life imprisonment but escaped in 1621, hidden by his wife in a chest meant for books.
The pendulum later swung back. When the stadholder William II died suddenly in 1650, Holland's regents left the office vacant. Under the Grand Pensionary Johan de Witt, the First Stadholderless Period lasted until 1672, the high point of regent government.
Worked example: paying for a fleet
Imagine that in 1665 the Republic needs money for a new war fleet. The proposal goes to the States General, but its delegates cannot simply vote yes. They report to their provincial States. In Holland, the States include one vote for the nobility and one each for eighteen towns, and each town delegation must consult its own council of regents. Amsterdam's merchants might support the fleet to protect trade; an inland town might grumble about the cost.
Once Holland agrees, it presses the poorer provinces, which may delay until they win concessions elsewhere. Each province then raises its quota in its own way, through excise taxes on beer, meat, salt or soap, or through loans. In fact the Republic ran several separate admiralties, so even the ships were built and manned by different regional boards.
The system was slow and often frustrating. Yet it forced bargaining, spread power among many hands and made it hard for any one person to rule alone. Critics saw paralysis; defenders saw liberty.
