Skip to main content

In October 1869, a party of Canadian surveyors began marking out square lots across the farms of the Red River settlement, in what is now Manitoba. A group of local men walked onto the chain, stood on it and told them to stop. Their leader was a twenty-five-year-old Métis named Louis Riel. Canada had bought the territory from the Hudson's Bay Company, but nobody had asked the people who lived there.

The Métis and Red River

The Métis are a distinct people descended from fur trade unions between First Nations women and European men, mostly French and Scottish. By the 1800s they had their own language, Michif, and a way of life built around the bison hunts and the river-lot farms of Red River. When Canada prepared to take over without consultation, the Métis feared for their land, language and faith.

Riel's National Committee blocked the new governor, seized Upper Fort Garry and formed a provisional government to negotiate terms. In March 1870 that government executed Thomas Scott, an Ontario Protestant who had defied it. Scott's execution enraged Protestant Ontario and made Riel a hated figure there, while French Catholic Quebec tended to see him as a defender of their own people. Ottawa nevertheless accepted most of the Métis demands. The Manitoba Act of 1870 created a small province with French and English and protection for church schools, and it set aside 1.4 million acres of land for Métis children. In practice the land was slow to arrive, the promises were often fulfilled with paper certificates easily bought up by speculators, and many Métis moved west. Riel, facing arrest, went into exile in the United States.

The Numbered Treaties

To open the prairies to settlement and a railway, the crown negotiated a series of agreements with First Nations. Between 1871 and 1921 eleven Numbered Treaties covered most of the prairies and the north. They provided reserves, small yearly payments, farming tools, schools, and promises about hunting and fishing. Their meaning was disputed from the start. Crown officials saw the treaties as land surrenders, while many First Nations leaders understood them as agreements to share the land. Their accounts stress kinship and mutual help, which the English texts do not capture.

First Nations negotiators fought for better terms. At Fort Carlton in 1876, Cree leaders secured additions to Treaty 6, including famine relief and a medicine chest clause, which many First Nations read as a promise of health care. The Cree leader Mistahimaskwa, known as Big Bear, refused to sign for six years, warning that his people would lose their freedom. He signed only in 1882, when the bison were gone and his band was starving. Officials sometimes withheld rations to push bands onto reserves.

The Indian Act of 1876 gathered earlier laws into one statute that defined who counted as a status Indian and gave federal agents sweeping control over reserve life. Its rules were also unequal between men and women. Under the Indian Act, a First Nations woman who married a man without status lost her own status, along with her children, while a man who married outside kept his and passed it to his wife. That rule lasted until 1985.

1885

By 1884 Métis on the South Saskatchewan River, along with settlers and First Nations, had petitioned Ottawa for years without result. They invited Riel back from Montana. In March 1885 he declared another provisional government at Batoche, and fighting broke out at Duck Lake. Some Cree warriors killed nine people at Frog Lake. The government's answer came quickly: troops were rushed west on the unfinished Canadian Pacific Railway, reaching the prairies in about a week. The Métis were defeated at Batoche in May.

Riel was tried for high treason in Regina before a jury of six English-speaking Protestants. He rejected his lawyers' plea that he was insane, and he was hanged on 16 November 1885. Big Bear and the Cree leader Pitikwahanapiwiyin, known as Poundmaker, were jailed although both had tried to restrain the fighting, and eight Cree and Assiniboine men were hanged together at Battleford. Nine days before Riel's death, the railway's last spike was driven in British Columbia.

Thousands of Chinese labourers had built the most dangerous sections of that line. Once it was nearly finished, Ottawa moved to keep their families out. In 1885 Parliament placed a fifty-dollar head tax on Chinese immigrants, raised to five hundred dollars by 1903. In 1923 a new law shut out almost all Chinese immigrants until 1947, and in 2006 the government formally apologized.

Worked example: Riel, traitor or founder?

Riel's reputation has swung wildly. To Macdonald's government he was a rebel who twice took up arms against the crown; the law of treason was clear. To many in Quebec he was a French Catholic hanged by an English Protestant majority, and his execution shook national politics for years. To many Métis he was a leader who defended a people Ottawa ignored.

A fair judgment separates the questions. Did he break the law of the time? Yes. Were the grievances behind 1885 real and long neglected? Yes, by the government's own later admissions. Was the trial fair? Historians question the jury's makeup. Manitoba now honors him as its founder. Holding all these answers at once is harder than choosing one, and it is what history requires.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who are the Métis?
2. How did Ontario react to Thomas Scott's execution?
3. What land did the Manitoba Act set aside in 1870?
4. How did Crown and First Nations views of the treaties differ?
5. What did many First Nations read Treaty 6's medicine chest clause as?
6. Under the Indian Act, what happened to a woman who married a man without status?
7. How did troops reach the prairies quickly in 1885?
8. What did Parliament impose on Chinese immigrants in 1885?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia