Skip to main content

In the autumn of 1755, the men of Grand-Pré, a farming village on the Bay of Fundy, were summoned to their church to hear an order from the British governor. When they had gathered, the doors were guarded and the order was read: their lands, houses and livestock were forfeit, and they and their families would be removed from the province. They were Acadians, and their removal is remembered in French as le Grand Dérangement, the great upheaval.

Acadia between empires

Acadia, the French name for the Maritime region, changed hands repeatedly. In the Treaty of Utrecht of 1713, France ceded mainland Nova Scotia to Britain, but its French-speaking Catholic farmers stayed. They had built a prosperous way of life on the tidal marshes. Acadians farmed salt marshes reclaimed from the sea with dykes and sluice gates called aboiteaux.

British governors repeatedly demanded that the Acadians swear allegiance to the crown. Most offered a conditional oath that excused them from bearing arms against France or their Mi'kmaq neighbors, and for decades they were known as the neutral French. As war with France loomed again, the governor and his council decided neutrality was no longer acceptable. Beginning in 1755, British authorities deported most Acadians after they refused an unconditional oath of loyalty. Over the next eight years roughly ten thousand were expelled, scattered among the British colonies, France and England. Thousands died of disease and shipwreck. Some reached Louisiana, where their descendants became the Cajuns.

The Mi'kmaq, allied with France, fought the British for years. Between 1725 and 1779 they and neighboring nations made a series of agreements with the crown. The Peace and Friendship Treaties ended hostilities and protected trade, but did not surrender any land. In 1999 the Supreme Court of Canada relied on treaties of 1760 and 1761 to uphold a Mi'kmaw right to fish for a moderate livelihood.

The fall of New France

The Seven Years' War, which began in North America in 1754, decided the fate of the continent. In 1759 a British fleet carried an army under James Wolfe up the St. Lawrence to besiege Quebec. After months of bombardment, Wolfe's troops climbed a steep path to the Plains of Abraham above the city on the night of 12 to 13 September. In the battle on the Plains of Abraham, both Wolfe and the French commander Montcalm were mortally wounded. Quebec surrendered, Montreal followed in 1760, and France formally gave up its North American mainland colonies in 1763.

Ruling a conquered people

Britain now governed about seventy thousand French-speaking Catholics who had no wish to become Protestants or Englishmen. It also faced undefeated Indigenous nations, who rose in war in 1763 when the British cut back customary gifts. The crown's answer was the Royal Proclamation of 1763. Besides drawing a boundary for settlement, it set a rule for land. The Royal Proclamation said only the crown could acquire Indigenous land, through public agreement with the nation concerned. That rule became the legal foundation of the treaty process in Canada, and the Proclamation is still named in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

The Proclamation also promised English law and an assembly to attract British settlers, but few came. Governor Guy Carleton concluded that Quebec would stay French and that the loyalty of its clergy and seigneurs mattered more. The Quebec Act of 1774 kept French civil law and let Catholics hold office without renouncing their faith. It also let the Church collect its tithes and stretched the province's boundaries to the Ohio valley.

Loyalists and new provinces

The American Revolution brought a wave of refugees north. Loyalists settled in Nova Scotia, the new colony of New Brunswick, and along the upper St. Lawrence and Lake Ontario. Among them were thousands of Black Loyalists, many promised freedom and land for serving the crown, who too often received poor plots or none. In 1784 the Haldimand Proclamation granted the Mohawk and other Haudenosaunee allies land along the Grand River, a tract later whittled down by sales and settlement and still the subject of claims today.

The English-speaking Loyalists wanted English law and an elected assembly, while the Canadiens wanted to keep what the Quebec Act had given them. Britain divided the problem in two. The Constitutional Act of 1791 split the colony into Upper and Lower Canada, each with its own elected assembly. Upper Canada, today's Ontario, used English law; Lower Canada, today's Quebec, kept French civil law. Real power, however, stayed with governors and appointed councils.

Worked example: four views of the Quebec Act

Imagine four people reading the Quebec Act in 1774. A seigneur near Trois-Rivières is relieved: his rights and the civil law governing his estate survive. The bishop of Quebec sees an extraordinary concession from a Protestant empire. A British merchant in Montreal is furious, having expected English commercial law and an assembly. A colonist in Massachusetts sees London building a Catholic, autocratic province on his frontier, and adds the act to his grievances against the king.

Each reading is partly right. The act was generous to Catholic Canadiens, and also a calculation that kept them loyal when the American colonies rebelled. Its decision to tolerate a different religion and legal tradition within one state began a pattern: Canada would be held together less by uniformity than by bargains between distinct communities.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How did Acadians farm the Bay of Fundy marshes?
2. Why did British authorities deport the Acadians?
3. What did the Peace and Friendship Treaties not do?
4. What happened to Wolfe and Montcalm in 1759?
5. What land rule did the Royal Proclamation of 1763 set?
6. What did the Quebec Act of 1774 do?
7. What did the Haldimand Proclamation of 1784 grant?
8. What did the Constitutional Act of 1791 create?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia