Skip to main content

For a century after their arrival the Mexica were junior partners in other people's wars. Then, within a single generation, they overthrew their masters, reshaped their own history and began the conquests that made them the dominant power in Mesoamerica. The turning point came in 1428.

A crisis in Azcapotzalco

The Tepanec ruler Tezozomoc had made Azcapotzalco the leading power of the basin during a reign of several decades. When he died in 1426, his son Maxtla seized the throne from the heir Tezozomoc had chosen and set out to tighten his grip on the cities under him. Around the same time the Mexica ruler Chimalpopoca died, quite possibly murdered on Maxtla's orders. The Mexica nobility now faced a choice between deeper submission and open war.

Itzcoatl and the war of 1428

They chose war, and a new ruler to lead it. Itzcoatl, "Obsidian Serpent," was a son of the first king Acamapichtli, said to have been born to a woman of low rank, and he owed his throne to ability and to the backing of the warrior nobles. He found an ally in Nezahualcoyotl, the exiled heir of Texcoco, whose father had been killed by Tepanec forces and who had spent years in hiding. The city of Huexotzinco, east of the volcanoes, also sent troops. In 1428 the allies besieged and destroyed Azcapotzalco.

The victors divided the old Tepanec domain among three cities: Tenochtitlan, Texcoco and Tlacopan, a Tepanec town that had sided with the winners. Several later sources say the spoils of future wars were split so that Tenochtitlan and Texcoco each took two fifths and Tlacopan one fifth, though other accounts describe the shares differently. Over the following decades the partnership grew lopsided. Texcoco remained a great center of law and learning, but by 1500 Tenochtitlan clearly led.

Reshaping the past

Victory brought a new view of history. A Nahua account collected in the sixteenth century reports that under Itzcoatl the old painted histories were burned, because the rulers judged it unwise for common people to know them. Historians take this as a sign that the Mexica deliberately reshaped their past, giving Huitzilopochtli a grander role and their own people a nobler destiny. Destroying records to control memory was not a European invention in Mexico.

Many chronicles credit these changes, and much of the empire's later policy, to Tlacaelel, a nephew of Itzcoatl who held the title cihuacoatl, the ruler's chief adviser. In these accounts Tlacaelel serves several kings, promotes the cult of Huitzilopochtli and plans conquests. Yet he stands out in only one group of sources, the chronicle of the friar Diego Durán and a related Nahua history, and barely appears in others. Some historians suspect that his descendants inflated his role in the stories they passed on.

Expansion and famine

Under Moctezuma I, also called Motecuhzoma Ilhuicamina, who ruled from 1440 to 1469, the alliance pushed east toward the Gulf coast and south into Oaxaca. His reign also brought disaster. In the early 1450s frost and drought ruined harvests several years running, and in the worst year, 1454, starving families sold themselves or their children to the Totonacs of the Gulf coast in exchange for maize. Some historians link it to a new drive to secure food tribute from the lowlands, and to a deepened concern with feeding the gods.

Victories and limits

Moctezuma's successor, his grandson Axayacatl, ruled from 1469 to 1481. In 1473 he settled the old rivalry with the twin city by force: Tenochtitlan conquered Tlatelolco, killed its ruler and placed it under governors. A few years later, probably in 1478 or 1479, Axayacatl marched west against the Tarascans, also called the Purépecha, a powerful kingdom centered on Lake Pátzcuaro. The Tarascans destroyed most of his army, and their border remained a fortified frontier the empire never crossed.

The next ruler, Tizoc, reigned only from 1481 to 1486 and won little. His brother Ahuitzotl, who ruled from 1486 to 1502, carried the empire's conquests farthest, as far as Xoconochco on the Pacific coast near today's border with Guatemala. Moctezuma II, who came to the throne in 1502, spent more effort holding and reorganizing what had been won than adding new lands.

Worked example: whose story of Tlatelolco?

Accounts from the Tenochtitlan tradition explain the war of 1473 as Tlatelolco's fault. They say its ruler, Moquihuix, mistreated his wife, who was Axayacatl's sister, plotted with enemy cities and insulted the Mexica. Tenochtitlan, in these accounts, simply answered an outrage.

A historian asks who gained from that version. Tlatelolco had grown rich on its great market and had its own royal line, which made it a rival on Tenochtitlan's doorstep. The detailed narratives come mostly from the victors' side, and a story of a cruel husband and a wronged princess turns a war of conquest into a defense of family honor. That does not prove the story false, since marriage alliances in Mesoamerica did break down in anger. But it suggests reading the account as justification as well as report. Little of Tlatelolco's own version of the war survives in comparable detail, and when only the winner's account is full, the silence of the loser is itself part of the evidence.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Maxtla do after Tezozomoc died in 1426?
2. Who was Nezahualcoyotl when the war against Azcapotzalco began?
3. According to several sources, how were the alliance's spoils divided?
4. What does a Nahua account say happened to the old painted histories under Itzcoatl?
5. Who was Tlacaelel?
6. Why do some historians doubt the huge role given to Tlacaelel?
7. What did starving families do in the famine year of 1454?
8. What happened when Axayacatl attacked the Tarascans?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia