Skip to main content

The stool hidden and found

The Golden Stool never fell into British hands. Its custodians hid it in the forest, and for two decades its location remained a closely guarded secret. Then, around 1920, laborers building a road came across the hiding place. They stripped some of its gold ornaments and sold them.

When the theft came to light in 1921, the outrage in Asante was intense. An Asante court tried the men responsible and sentenced them to death for violating the most sacred object of the nation. The colonial government faced a dilemma. The British commuted the death sentences to banishment, but they did not ignore Asante feeling. Having learned from 1900, the government declared that it had no intention of seizing or interfering with the Golden Stool. The anthropologist R. S. Rattray, then working for the colonial government, helped officials understand that the stool was the shrine of the nation, not a throne.

Prempeh returns

Prempeh I had spent years in exile, first on the coast, then in Sierra Leone and finally in the Seychelles, an island colony in the Indian Ocean. There he learned English, became an Anglican and kept up a quiet correspondence with his people. In 1924 the British allowed him to return to Kumasi, at first only as a private citizen. In 1926 he was recognized as Kumasihene, ruler of Kumasi alone, not of the wider union. He died in 1931.

Colonial rule had changed its strategy. Across its African colonies Britain now governed through local rulers wherever it could, a policy called indirect rule. In Asante that meant rebuilding the institutions it had broken. In 1935 Britain restored the Asante Confederacy, with Prempeh II as asantehene. The council of chiefs met again, and the king once more held authority over the member states, though under a British chief commissioner.

Cocoa and politics

The twentieth century brought a new source of wealth. Cocoa farms spread across the Asante forest, making many farmers and chiefs prosperous and making the region central to the colonial economy. Cocoa also gave Asante leaders the money and confidence to argue with whoever governed the country.

As independence approached in the 1950s, that argument became sharp. Kwame Nkrumah's government favored a strong central state. Many in Asante feared being ruled from Accra. The government froze the price it paid farmers for cocoa, using the profits for national development, which angered Asante growers. In response, the National Liberation Movement, founded in Kumasi in 1954, demanded a federal constitution that would protect the regions. The movement lost that struggle, and the new nation was built as a unitary state, but the debate about how much power regions and traditional rulers should keep has never fully ended.

The kingdom today

Ghana's constitution recognizes chiefs and forbids the state from creating or removing them. The asantehene has no formal political power but carries great influence, presiding over the Asante council of chiefs, settling land and chieftaincy disputes and supporting schools and health projects. Since 1999 the asantehene has been Osei Tutu II, who holds court at Manhyia Palace in Kumasi.

Many objects taken in the wars of 1874 and 1896 remain in British museums, and British law bars these national museums from permanently giving away most items in their collections. The Golden Stool remains at the heart of Asante identity. It still appears on great occasions, carried under its umbrella and resting on its own stool, never sat on.

Worked example: a loan, not a return

In 2024, during the celebrations of Osei Tutu II's twenty five years on the stool, gold regalia taken from Kumasi in 1874 and 1896 went on display at the Manhyia Palace Museum. They came from the British Museum and the Victoria and Albert Museum, and they came on loan. Why not simply give them back?

The museums pointed to that legal barrier, so a loan, reported as lasting three years with the option of renewal, was the route available. The Manhyia side welcomed the objects while making clear that the long-term aim was their permanent return. A museum in Los Angeles returned a smaller group of Asante objects outright in the same year, showing that not every institution faces the same limits.

How should we judge the arrangement? One view says a loan quietly affirms that the objects belong in London, since a borrower must give back what is lent. Another sees it as a practical step that put the regalia back in Kumasi now, rather than waiting years for a change in British law. A third points out that the objects were taken in punitive wars, and that the legal question cannot settle the moral one.

Each position takes something real into account. What the case shows clearly is that the story of Asante's conquest is not finished. The people who carried the gold away and the people from whom it was taken still have descendants, and those descendants are still negotiating what justice now requires.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the British do with the death sentences of 1921?
2. What did the colonial government declare after 1921 about the Golden Stool?
3. What position was Prempeh I given in 1926?
4. What did Britain restore in 1935?
5. What angered Asante cocoa growers in the 1950s?
6. What did the National Liberation Movement demand in 1954?
7. Who has been asantehene since 1999?
8. Why were the regalia sent in 2024 lent rather than returned?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia