Skip to main content

The man who solved the king's marriage problem came, like Wolsey, from nowhere. Thomas Cromwell was a blacksmith's son from Putney who had been a soldier, merchant and lawyer before he joined Wolsey's household. He survived his master's fall, entered the king's service and by 1534 was the king's principal secretary. For most of the 1530s he was the most powerful man in England after Henry.

Statute as a weapon

Cromwell's method was to make each change by act of Parliament, so that it carried the authority of king, Lords and Commons together. A royal order could be challenged. A statute was the law of the whole realm, and judges would enforce it. Between 1529 and 1536 the Reformation Parliament passed a stream of acts that remade the relations between church and crown.

The most famous of them, the Act in Restraint of Appeals of 1533, opened with a bold claim: "this realm of England is an empire." In the language of the time, an empire meant a realm subject to no outside authority, whether pope or emperor. The act said that English cases should be decided in England.

Enforcing obedience

New laws needed teeth. The Treason Act of 1534 made it treason to deny the king's titles in words, not only in deeds, for example by calling him a heretic or a tyrant. A careless remark in a tavern could now be a capital crime.

He also wanted to know exactly what the church owned. In 1535 royal commissioners compiled the Valor Ecclesiasticus, a survey valuing the income of every church office and religious house in England and Wales. It told the crown precisely how much it could gain by taking monastic property.

Wales and the realm

Cromwell's reach went beyond the church. The Laws in Wales Acts of 1535 and 1542 brought Wales under English law, gave Welsh counties and boroughs seats in Parliament, and required English for public office. Welsh gentry gained a voice at Westminster and a share in local government, while the Welsh language was shut out of official life. Historians still weigh the gains of union against the losses for a culture.

A revolution in government?

In 1953 the historian Geoffrey Elton argued that Cromwell carried out a "Tudor revolution in government," replacing rule through the king's household with national departments run by officials. A smaller, formal Privy Council took shape in these years, with its own clerk and minute book by 1540. Elton's critics, including David Starkey and John Guy, have replied that the change was slower and less planned, and that the king's private rooms and the courtiers who served there remained centers of power long after Cromwell. Most historians now accept that government became more formal in the 1530s, while doubting it was a single revolution.

Elton could make such arguments partly because of an accident. When Cromwell fell, his papers were seized, and thousands of letters sent to him passed into the royal archives.

The Pilgrimage of Grace

Change on this scale provoked the largest rising of the Tudor age. In October 1536 rebellion broke out in Lincolnshire, then spread across Yorkshire and the north. Its leader was Robert Aske, a Yorkshire lawyer, who called the rising a pilgrimage and gave his followers a banner showing the five wounds of Christ. Perhaps thirty thousand men gathered near Doncaster, far more than the king's forces. Their demands mixed religion and politics: restore the monasteries, punish heretic bishops, remove "low born" councillors such as Cromwell, and ease taxes.

The king's commander, the Duke of Norfolk, could not win a battle, so he talked. Norfolk ended the rising by promising a general pardon and a parliament in the north. The rebels went home. Early in 1537 a fresh rising gave Henry his excuse to break the promises. Around two hundred people were executed, Aske among them, hanged in chains at York.

Cromwell's own fall came in 1540. He had arranged Henry's marriage to Anne of Cleves, which the king hated, and his enemies accused him of heresy and treason. Cromwell was condemned by act of attainder, a statute declaring him guilty without a trial, the very tool he had used against others. He was beheaded in July 1540.

Worked example: the parish register

In 1538 Cromwell ordered every parish priest to record each baptism, marriage and burial in a book kept in a locked chest. In fact the order gave England one of the best population records in early modern Europe.

Suppose a village register shows 20 baptisms and 12 burials a year through the 1560s. Births exceed deaths by 8 a year, so the village is growing, unless people are leaving. Now suppose one year shows 45 burials, many in late summer. That points to an epidemic or a harvest failure. By tracing families across generations, historians have estimated ages at marriage, family size and life expectancy for ordinary people who left no letters. An order meant to tighten control over the parishes became, centuries later, a way to recover the lives of people the state had never noticed as individuals.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was Thomas Cromwell's background before royal service?
2. Why did Cromwell make his changes by act of Parliament?
3. What did "empire" mean in the Act in Restraint of Appeals?
4. What did the Treason Act of 1534 add to the law?
5. What was the Valor Ecclesiasticus of 1535?
6. What did the Laws in Wales Acts require of public officials?
7. Who led the Pilgrimage of Grace in Yorkshire?
8. What happened to Cromwell's papers when he fell?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia