Skip to main content

In June 1856 the Taiping stood at a peak. Their armies broke the Qing camps that had been besieging Nanjing, and they held a broad stretch of the middle and lower Yangzi. Within three months the movement had torn itself apart.

The voice of God against the Son of God

Yang Xiuqing, the East King, ran the state day to day, and he held a weapon no one else had: he spoke, in trances, as God the Father. Through this voice he rebuked other kings and even Hong. On one occasion, speaking as God the Father, Yang ordered that Hong himself be flogged for mistreating women of the palace, and Hong knelt to accept the punishment before it was remitted. Hong could not refuse the voice of God without undermining the faith on which his own authority rested.

In August 1856 Yang went further. He demanded the title "Ten Thousand Years," reserved for Hong, the traditional salute to an emperor. To many, this looked like a step toward replacing the Heavenly King.

The Tianjing Incident

Hong secretly summoned commanders who resented Yang. On the night of 2 September 1856, troops led by Wei Changhui, the North King, entered Nanjing and killed Yang Xiuqing and his family. In the following days thousands of Yang's followers were disarmed, lured into confinement and slaughtered. Estimates of the dead run as high as 20,000, though the figure is uncertain. Taiping sources say little about these days, and much of what we know comes from foreign visitors and from later confessions.

Shi Dakai, the Wing King, hurried to Nanjing and protested the killings. Wei turned on him, and Shi escaped while his family was murdered. Facing anger from the army, Hong had Wei executed in November. Shi returned to run the government, but Hong distrusted him and gave power to his own elder brothers. In 1857 Shi Dakai left Nanjing with an army of his own, perhaps tens of thousands strong, and fought independently for six years across south and west China. In 1863 he was trapped at the Dadu River in Sichuan and executed by the Qing.

What the killings cost

Within a year the movement had lost its ablest administrator, two of its founding kings and one of its best generals. Worse, the voice of God the Father had been silenced by the Son of God's own order, which shook believers. Hong withdrew further into religious writing and trusted only relatives. Many soldiers began to ask whether the kingdom's leaders were any better than the officials they had rebelled against. Some deserted, and Qing commanders used the confusion to retake ground along the Yangzi, including Wuchang at the end of 1856.

A reformer from Hong Kong

In 1859 Hong's cousin Hong Rengan reached Nanjing. He had lived for years in Hong Kong, working with missionaries, and he knew far more about the outside world than anyone at the Taiping court. Hong made him the Shield King and chief minister.

Hong Rengan wrote a program called A New Treatise on Aids to Administration. It proposed railways, banks and newspapers, along with steamships, patents for inventors, a postal service, hospitals and insurance. It urged that foreigners be treated as equals in diplomacy rather than as tribute bearers. Hong Xiuquan approved much of it, but in wartime little was done, and generals resented an outsider who had never led troops.

The generals' revival

Military recovery came from younger commanders. Chen Yucheng, the Heroic King, and Li Xiucheng, the Loyal King, won a series of victories. In May 1860 they broke the Qing siege camp at Nanjing, and in June Li Xiucheng took Suzhou, one of the wealthiest cities in the empire. The Taiping pushed into the Yangzi delta and in August 1860 approached Shanghai, where British and French troops drove them back. The kingdom had survived its crisis, but its leadership was now split between a reclusive Heavenly King, his relatives and generals who acted largely on their own.

Worked example: two programs for a modern China

Compare Hong Rengan's treatise with what Qing officials would attempt in the 1860s and after. Both admired Western steamships and guns. The Qing reformers, however, mainly wanted arsenals, shipyards and translation schools while keeping the Confucian order of government unchanged. Hong Rengan went further. He imagined newspapers that would let rulers hear complaints, banks that would mobilize savings and patent laws that would reward inventors. He saw technology as part of a wider system of institutions.

Why did a rebel exile see this more clearly? He had lived in a British colony and watched how its press, courts and markets worked. Why did his ideas fail? He lacked power: the Heavenly King cared most about doctrine, the generals about the war, and no one trusted a newcomer who had sat out the fighting. The lesson is general. A good reform plan needs more than good ideas. It needs people with the authority and the trust to carry it out, and a state at peace long enough to try.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What title did Yang Xiuqing demand in 1856?
2. What did Yang once order, speaking as God the Father?
3. Who led the troops that killed Yang Xiuqing in 1856?
4. What did Shi Dakai do in 1857?
5. Where had Hong Rengan lived before reaching Nanjing?
6. What did Hong Rengan's New Treatise propose?
7. What did Chen Yucheng and Li Xiucheng achieve in May 1860?
8. Which wealthy city did Li Xiucheng take in June 1860?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia