Skip to main content

For a long time, visitors and scholars told a simple story about the Swahili coast: foreigners from Arabia or Persia arrived, built towns and civilized the shore. The evidence now tells a slower and more interesting story, in which local farming villages grew into Muslim trading towns over several centuries, absorbing newcomers as they went.

A shared coastal culture

From around the sixth and seventh centuries AD, small communities of farmers, fishers and iron workers lived along the coast and on the nearby islands. They made a distinctive kind of pottery, cooking pots decorated with bands of incised triangles. Archaeologists call this shared pottery style Triangular Incised Ware, also known as the Tana tradition. It turns up from southern Somalia to Mozambique and the Comoros, and similar pottery over such a long stretch suggests that these villages were in regular contact, linked by canoes and coastal trade long before the stone towns appeared.

These people spoke early forms of the language that became Swahili, a member of the Bantu family whose closest relatives include Comorian and the Mijikenda and Pokomo languages of the Kenyan coast. They grew sorghum and millet, kept chickens and some cattle, fished the reefs and worked iron. Already they were trading with ships from the north.

Early ports

Some villages became ports. Unguja Ukuu, on Zanzibar, was an early port where excavators found glazed pottery from the Persian Gulf of the seventh to tenth centuries, along with glass vessels and beads. At Chibuene in southern Mozambique and Mahilaka in Madagascar, similar finds show that the trade reached far to the south.

The clearest sequence comes from Shanga, a town in the Lamu archipelago excavated by Mark Horton in the 1980s. Under the ruins of its stone mosque he found traces of earlier ones on the same spot. At Shanga the earliest of a series of mosques was built of timber, perhaps in the late eighth century, and each later one was rebuilt larger, first in timber and then in coral stone. The rebuilding traces a community slowly growing and converting, not one planted all at once by foreign settlers.

The Shirazi legend

The coast's own traditions told a different story. Many ruling families claimed descent from Shiraz, a city in Persia. In the Kilwa Chronicle, Ali bin al-Hasan, said to be a son of a ruler of Shiraz, bought Kilwa island from a local king for a quantity of cloth. In some tellings he paid enough cloth to encircle the whole island, and in others the local king later regretted the deal and was tricked out of trying to undo it.

Historians have long debated what to make of this. Colonial scholars read the legend literally, as proof that the towns were foreign colonies. Later scholars, struck by the African roots shown by archaeology, treated "Shirazi" mainly as a status claim, a way for elite families to link themselves to the prestige of the Islamic heartlands. Some suggested that the "Shirazi" were really Swahili migrants from the northern coast who moved south and kept a story of distant origins.

What ancient DNA added

In 2023 a team of geneticists and archaeologists published a study of ancient DNA from about eighty people buried at six coastal towns between roughly 1250 and 1800. The study found ancestry roughly half African, mostly through women, and half from Asia, mostly Persian and Indian, mostly through men. The mixing appears to have begun around 1000 AD. Later burials, after about 1500, show more ancestry from Arabia.

The finding pleased neither old camp completely. It showed that the Shirazi legends held a real memory of Persian newcomers. But it also showed that those newcomers married into African families, and the culture their children grew up in, its language, its kinship and its daily life, remained rooted in the coast. Genes tell us who had children with whom; they do not tell us whose culture was "really" in charge. The study's authors themselves warned against reading it as a verdict on identity, and some coastal scholars criticized how the results were reported in the press. These results are recent, from a limited number of graves, and will be refined.

Worked example: three answers to one question

Ask "Who founded Kilwa?" and set out the evidence. The chronicle says a prince from Shiraz bought the island. Archaeology shows people living at Kilwa well before the dynasty's coins appear, making local pottery and slowly adopting stone building and Islam. Ancient DNA shows that Persian men did arrive and had children with local women.

A careless reader picks one source and throws out the rest. A careful reader notices that each answers a slightly different question. Archaeology answers "Who lived here and how did life change?" The DNA answers "Whose descendants are buried here?" The chronicle answers "How did the ruling family want to be remembered?" Put together, they suggest a town that was African in its roots, open to newcomers who married in, and ruled by a family that found it useful to stress its foreign link. That combined picture is less dramatic than either "foreign colony" or "purely local," and it fits all the evidence.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What do archaeologists call the coast's early shared pottery style?
2. What suggests the early coastal villages were in regular contact?
3. What did excavators find at Unguja Ukuu on Zanzibar?
4. What was the earliest of Shanga's mosques built of?
5. What does Shanga's mosque sequence suggest?
6. According to the Kilwa Chronicle, how did Ali bin al-Hasan get Kilwa island?
7. What ancestry did the 2023 ancient DNA study find?
8. In the 2023 study, the Asian ancestry came mostly through whom?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia