Between 1933 and 1936 Spanish politics polarized until the middle ground almost disappeared. Each side came to believe the other was preparing to destroy it, and each could point to evidence.
The right returns
In the election of November 1933 the left ran divided, and the anarchists campaigned for abstention. The winner was a new Catholic coalition, the CEDA, led by José María Gil Robles, which became the largest party in parliament. The CEDA defended religion and property and was ambiguous about the Republic itself; its youth rallies borrowed the style of fascist movements abroad. President Alcalá-Zamora distrusted Gil Robles, so the Radical Party of Alejandro Lerroux governed with CEDA votes. The new governments slowed land reform, let rural wages fall and reversed parts of the religious legislation. The left called these the "two black years"; the right called them a correction.
A small fascist party also appeared. In October 1933 José Antonio Primo de Rivera, son of the former dictator, founded the Falange Española, which soon merged with another tiny group. It won no seats in 1933 or 1936, but its gunmen and those of its enemies traded killings in the streets.
October 1934
Socialists watched with alarm as Hitler took power in Germany and, in February 1934, the Austrian chancellor Dollfuss crushed the Socialists of Vienna. The Socialist leader Largo Caballero began to speak openly of revolution. When three CEDA ministers entered the government on 4 October 1934, the left treated it as the first step toward fascism and called a general strike. In Barcelona, Lluís Companys, president of the Generalitat, proclaimed a Catalan State within a federal Spanish republic, a bid that collapsed within hours. In Asturias, however, coal miners staged an armed revolution that held much of the region for about two weeks.
The government sent troops, including the Spanish Legion and Moroccan Regulares from the army in Africa, with General Franco coordinating operations from Madrid. The fighting and the repression that followed killed well over a thousand people, and many thousands were jailed. Revolutionaries had murdered priests and others; troops and police carried out summary executions and torture. The left remembered October 1934 as heroic resistance to fascism. The right remembered it as proof that the left would not accept an election it had lost. Historians still argue over which reading weighs more, but both memories fed the war to come.
The Popular Front
Scandal destroyed the Radicals in 1935, when bribes paid to party figures to license a rigged roulette game, the Straperlo, came to light. A new election was called for February 1936. On the left, Republicans, Socialists, Communists and the small Marxist POUM formed the Popular Front, an electoral alliance whose program promised an amnesty for those jailed after October 1934. Many anarchists voted this time, largely to free their comrades. On 16 February the Popular Front won a clear majority of seats.
A spring of fear
Azaña returned as prime minister and in May became president. The new government restored the Catalan statute and restarted land reform. In Extremadura, in late March, tens of thousands of laborers occupied estates, and the government chose to legalize much of what they had done. Strikes multiplied, churches were burned in some towns, and the Falange, banned in March, kept up its campaign of attacks. The Socialist party split between Largo Caballero's revolutionary wing and the moderates around Indalecio Prieto, which left the government weak.
Senior officers were already plotting. The coordinator was General Emilio Mola, who signed his secret instructions as "the Director". On 12 July 1936 gunmen killed José del Castillo, a lieutenant of the Assault Guards. Early the next morning, Assault Guards and Socialist militants took the monarchist leader José Calvo Sotelo from his home and murdered him. That an opposition leader could be killed by men tied to the state's own police convinced many on the right that the Republic could no longer protect them. The coup was launched four days later.
Worked example: how close was February 1936?
For decades the two sides told different stories about the 1936 election. Supporters of the Republic stressed that the Popular Front won a legal majority. Franco's regime later called the vote fraudulent and used the charge to justify the rising. The truth is more interesting than either story. In popular votes the two blocs were close, roughly even by many estimates, but the electoral system gave the winning list in each province most of its seats, which magnified the Popular Front's narrow lead.
In 2017 the historians Manuel Álvarez Tardío and Roberto Villa García published a detailed study arguing that irregularities in several provinces, during the count and in the review of results by the new parliament, shifted a number of seats to the left. Other scholars accept that there were irregularities on both sides but doubt that they changed who won. The careful conclusion is that the Popular Front most likely won, though by less than its seat total suggested, and that no reasonable reading of the evidence turns the election into grounds for overthrowing a government by force. Disputed elections call for courts and recounts, not for armies.
