In the thirty-seven years after Peter's death, six rulers sat on the Russian throne: Catherine I, Peter II, Anna, the infant Ivan VI, Elizabeth and Peter III. Five of them were women or children. Klyuchevsky called the period the era of palace revolutions, and the phrase stuck, because again and again the guards regiments in the capital decided who ruled. The Preobrazhensky and Semyonovsky regiments, staffed largely by nobles, had become kingmakers.
Catherine I and Peter II
When Peter died, many great families favored his grandson, Alexei's son Peter. But Alexander Menshikov, Peter's old favorite, and the guards backed the widow, and Catherine I was proclaimed empress. In 1726 a small Supreme Privy Council was created to manage business. Catherine died in 1727, and the boy Peter II, aged eleven, succeeded her. Menshikov planned to marry him to his own daughter, but he overreached. In 1727 Menshikov was exiled to Berezov in Siberia, where he died two years later. The court moved back to Moscow, and the Dolgoruky family took his place. Then, in January 1730, Peter II died of smallpox, on the day set for his wedding to a Dolgoruky princess.
Anna and the Conditions
The Supreme Privy Council, led by Prince Dmitry Golitsyn, now made a bold move. It offered the throne to Anna, a daughter of Ivan V and the widowed duchess of Courland, on written conditions. Without the council's consent she could not declare war, make peace, levy taxes, grant high ranks, spend state revenue or punish nobles without trial, and she was not to marry or name an heir. The worked example looks at what happened next. The result, on 25 February 1730, was that Anna tore up the Conditions and ruled as autocrat.
Anna relied heavily on her favorite from Courland, Ernst Johann Biron, and on other officials of Baltic German origin. Later Russian writers called her reign the Bironovshchina and painted it as a time of German oppression, though recent historians see a more mixed regime in which Russian grandees also held power. Anna made real concessions to the nobility. A Cadet Corps opened in 1731 to train noble sons as officers, the single inheritance rule was repealed, and in 1736 noble service was limited to a term of twenty-five years. Her court was also known for cruel entertainments: in 1740 a prince who had been made a court jester was married to a Kalmyk servant and the couple were made to spend the night in a palace built of ice on the frozen Neva.
Elizabeth
Anna died in October 1740, leaving the throne to her great-nephew Ivan VI, a baby two months old. Within three weeks Biron's regency was overthrown, and the baby's mother, Anna Leopoldovna, took over. On the night of 24 to 25 November 1741, Elizabeth, Peter the Great's daughter, seized the throne at the head of a company of Preobrazhensky grenadiers. The infant emperor spent the rest of his life in prison and was killed by his guards at Shlisselburg in 1764 when an officer tried to free him.
Elizabeth vowed never to sign a death sentence, and none was carried out in her reign, though flogging with the knout and mutilation continued. Her court favored French fashion and Italian architecture, and Bartolomeo Rastrelli began the Winter Palace in 1754. In 1755 Ivan Shuvalov and Mikhail Lomonosov helped found Moscow University. Lomonosov, the son of a fisherman from the White Sea coast, was a chemist, poet and grammarian, proof of how far talent could rise. Internal customs duties were abolished in 1753. In the Seven Years' War Russia fought Prussia, defeated Frederick II at Kunersdorf in 1759 and briefly occupied Berlin in 1760.
Peter III
Elizabeth died in December 1761. Her nephew Peter III, born in Kiel as duke of Holstein, admired Frederick II and promptly made peace with Prussia, giving back Russia's conquests. His manifesto of February 1762 freed nobles from compulsory state service. He also abolished the Secret Chancellery, the political police, and eased the persecution of Old Believers. But he offended the guards by planning a war with Denmark for the sake of Holstein, and he spoke of putting aside his wife. On 28 June 1762 the guards proclaimed her empress. Peter abdicated and died a week later at Ropsha, in the custody of Alexei Orlov. The official cause was colic.
Worked example: the Conditions of 1730
For a few weeks in 1730 Russia came close to a written limit on autocracy. Why did it fail? Start with who wrote the Conditions. The council was small, and the Golitsyns and Dolgorukys dominated it. To the hundreds of lesser nobles who had come to Moscow for the young tsar's wedding and stayed for his funeral, the plan looked like rule by a few great families. Several groups drew up their own projects asking for wider noble participation, but they could not agree.
When Anna received a large delegation of nobles and guards officers on 25 February, they petitioned her to restore full autocracy, and officers called out their support. She tore up the document. The lesson reaches beyond Russia: limits on power last only when a broad coalition believes it will benefit from them. A charter written for a narrow circle invites the excluded to prefer a single ruler.
