Skip to main content

The spring of 1848 in Paris was a season of clubs, posters and endless argument. By early summer, it had become a season of fear. Moderates feared the crowds of the east end; workers feared that the assembly they had helped elect would undo everything they had won. In June the two fears met in the bloodiest street fighting Paris had yet seen.

From May to June

On 15 May a demonstration in support of Polish independence marched to the assembly, and radical demonstrators invaded the chamber. In the confusion one of them declared the assembly dissolved and named a new government. The National Guard cleared the hall within hours. The veteran revolutionaries Armand Barbès and Auguste Blanqui, the chemist François Raspail and the worker Albert were arrested, and the Luxembourg Commission was shut. The radicals had lost their leaders, and moderates had a reason to act.

Their target was the National Workshops. Enrollment had swelled to more than a hundred thousand men, and to conservatives the workshops looked like an expensive, idle army of the discontented. On 21 June the government ordered young unmarried members to join the army and others to leave for public works in the provinces. In practice, the workshops were closing.

Four days of fighting

On 23 June barricades rose across eastern Paris. The assembly gave full powers to the war minister, General Eugène Cavaignac, who brought in regular troops and artillery. Among the government's most determined fighters was the Mobile Guard, a force raised in February from young unemployed men of Paris, often from the same streets as the insurgents. Class did not decide every loyalty.

On 25 June the Archbishop of Paris, Denis Affre, climbed a barricade carrying a green branch to plead for peace. He was shot while trying to stop the fighting and died two days later. By 26 June the rising was crushed. Estimates vary, but thousands died, some insurgents were shot after capture, around twelve thousand people were arrested, and thousands were sentenced to deportation, though many were later released.

Alexis de Tocqueville, a deputy who watched the fighting, wrote in his recollections that the June Days were not a struggle over who should govern but a fight over the order of society, a war of the poor against property. Karl Marx, writing from the other side, agreed that it was a class war and drew the opposite moral.

A new constitution

The assembly finished a constitution in November 1848. It created a single chamber elected by all adult men and a powerful president, also elected by all adult men. A deputy named Jules Grévy warned that a president with his own popular mandate could overthrow the assembly, and proposed abolishing the office or letting the assembly choose. Lamartine argued that the people must decide, and Grévy lost. As a safeguard, the president served four years and could not run again at once.

The obvious candidate was Cavaignac. The surprise was Louis-Napoléon Bonaparte, nephew of the emperor, who had spent years in exile and in prison after two failed coup attempts. He had written a short book on ending poverty, and his name meant more to peasants than any program.

The road to empire

Bonaparte quickly showed he was no puppet. After a conservative "party of order" won the elections of 1849, he worked with it and then against it. In May 1850 the assembly passed an electoral law that cut the electorate with a three-year residence rule, removing roughly a third of voters, many of them mobile workers. Barred from a second term, Bonaparte seized power on 2 December 1851, the anniversary of his uncle's victory at Austerlitz. He then restored universal male suffrage and asked voters to approve his coup, which a large majority did. Armed resistance in parts of the rural south led to tens of thousands of arrests. A year later he became Emperor Napoleon III.

Worked example: why did a democracy elect a Bonaparte?

On 10 December 1848 about 7.4 million Frenchmen voted. Bonaparte won about 5.4 million votes, Cavaignac about 1.4 million, Ledru-Rollin under 400,000, and Lamartine fewer than 20,000. Bonaparte took roughly three votes in every four. How?

Start with each group of voters. Peasants, the majority, resented the 45-centime tax and distrusted Paris; the Bonaparte name recalled order and glory. Many workers could not forgive Cavaignac for June, and a vote for Bonaparte was a vote against him. Conservative leaders backed Bonaparte because they thought him dull and easy to manage. Each group projected its hopes onto a man whose views were vague.

The lesson is uncomfortable. Universal suffrage gave power to the majority, but the majority used it to choose a man who would later limit freedom. A vote is a tool, not a guarantee. Rights survive when voting is joined to courts, a free press and limits on power that a single winner cannot sweep aside.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What happened in the French assembly on 15 May 1848?
2. Who was given full powers to crush the June rising?
3. Who mostly made up the Mobile Guard that fought the June insurgents?
4. How did Archbishop Denis Affre die in June 1848?
5. How did Tocqueville interpret the June Days?
6. What did the 1848 constitution say about the president's term?
7. What did the French electoral law of May 1850 do?
8. What did Louis-Napoléon do about voting after his 1851 coup?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia