The most influential early philosopher of race in America was W. E. B. Du Bois, a historian and sociologist trained at Harvard and in Berlin. He took up the question of what race is at a time when race science told Black Americans they were a lower order of humanity, and he gave an answer that still divides his readers.
A definition beyond biology
In 1897 Du Bois read a paper to the newly founded American Negro Academy in Washington. "The Conservation of Races" was Du Bois's 1897 address to the American Negro Academy, later printed as its second occasional paper. He granted that scientists could not agree on how many races there were or what physical marks separated them, and he argued that physical differences explain little about the parts groups have played in history. Then he offered his own definition:
"What, then, is a race? It is a vast family of human beings, generally of common blood and language, always of common history, traditions and impulses, who are both voluntarily and involuntarily striving together for the accomplishment of certain more or less vividly conceived ideals of life."
Notice the words "generally" and "always." Blood and language are only usually shared; in Du Bois's definition, what a race always shares is a common history, traditions and impulses. Race here is closer to a people or a nation than to a biological type. Du Bois went on to count eight "distinctly differentiated races" in this sense, including Slavs, Teutons, the English, Romance nations and "Negroes."
Why conserve a race?
The title points to Du Bois's practical aim. Many Black Americans hoped that racial identity would simply fade as legal equality arrived. Du Bois disagreed. He wrote that "the Negro people, as a race, have a contribution to make to civilization and humanity, which no other race can make." Du Bois urged Black Americans to keep their racial identity so they could offer humanity a distinct contribution, rather than dissolve into what he saw as an imitation of white American culture. Each race, in his picture, carries a message, and humanity is poorer if one is lost.
Appiah's objection
In 1985 the philosopher Kwame Anthony Appiah published a celebrated critique called "The Uncompleted Argument." He asked how we know which history belongs to which race. To say that twentieth century Black Americans share a history with people enslaved in the eighteenth century, or with ancient African kingdoms, we must already know who belongs to the group across time. And the only criterion that seems to do this is descent, which is biology again. Appiah argued that Du Bois's historical definition secretly relied on the biological idea it claimed to replace. If biological race is an illusion, as Appiah believed, then Du Bois's replacement fails with it.
Replies for Du Bois
Many scholars think Appiah was too quick. Some say shared descent need not mean shared biology in any deep sense: being descended from people treated as a group is a social fact as much as a genetic one. The philosopher Chike Jeffers has read the essay as offering a cultural theory of race, in which what matters is a living cultural community and its ideals, not genes. Others point to Du Bois's own later writing. Decades afterward Du Bois suggested that being Black in America was best defined by shared exposure to discrimination, such as having to ride the segregated car in Georgia. That later view looks forward to the social constructionism discussed earlier.
Being treated as a problem
Du Bois also gave race philosophy a first-person voice. In The Souls of Black Folk (1903) he described white acquaintances who circled around a question they never quite asked: "How does it feel to be a problem?" Du Bois wrote that white acquaintances never quite asked how it felt to be a problem, but that the question hung over every conversation. The point was philosophical as well as personal. A person can be turned, in the eyes of others, from a subject who asks questions into a question to be managed, and must then live with both views of himself.
Worked example: testing the definition
Apply Du Bois's definition to a modern case. Picture three people: a descendant of enslaved people in Mississippi, a recent immigrant from Ghana living in Chicago, and a Haitian American in Miami. Do they form one race in Du Bois's sense? Common blood holds only loosely, since West Africa is vast and diverse. Common language fails: English, Twi and Haitian Creole. Common history holds in part, through the Atlantic slave trade and the color line, but the Ghanaian's family history runs through colonial and independent Ghana instead. Striving together "voluntarily and involuntarily" fits better. All three may be treated alike by a landlord or a police officer, which is involuntary, and some may join shared causes, which is voluntary. Appiah would ask what unites them other than ancestry from one continent. A defender of Du Bois could answer that the shared treatment and the shared striving are enough, and that groups are often held together by a common future as much as a common past.
