Skip to main content

Progressives spoke of the people and of democracy, but their age was also one of the harshest in American history for those outside the circle of white, native-born citizens. Judging the era fairly means holding both facts at once. Many reforms widened democracy and protected the vulnerable. Others narrowed democracy or were turned against the people they claimed to help, sometimes by the same reformers.

Disfranchisement in the South

After Reconstruction, Black men in the South still voted in large numbers, despite fraud and violence. Then Southern states rewrote the rules. Mississippi's constitution of 1890 led the way with a poll tax and a literacy test that registrars could apply as they wished. Other states followed, often presenting the changes as progressive reforms to clean up corrupt elections. The results were drastic. In Louisiana, Black registered voters fell from more than 130,000 in 1896 to about 5,000 by 1900. Poor white voters lost ground too. The Supreme Court upheld Mississippi's scheme in 1898, and the white primary, an exclusive version of the progressive direct primary, closed off the one election that mattered in a one-party South.

Federal leaders did little to resist. Wilson's administration segregated workers in several federal departments beginning in 1913, and when the Boston editor William Monroe Trotter protested at the White House in 1914, Wilson ordered him out. Black Americans built their own institutions in response: churches, colleges, newspapers, women's clubs and, from 1909, the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People.

Native nations and the Dawes Act

Policy toward Native Americans was framed as reform as well. The Dawes Act of 1887 divided reservation land into individual plots and sold the "surplus" to settlers, on the theory that private farming would turn Native people into citizens. In practice it stripped away land on a vast scale. Native landholdings fell from about 138 million acres in 1887 to about 48 million by 1934. Boarding schools separated children from families to erase their languages and religions. Richard Henry Pratt, founder of the Carlisle Indian Industrial School, summed up the aim in 1892: "Kill the Indian in him, and save the man." In December 1890, the army killed at least 250 Lakota, many of them women and children, at Wounded Knee Creek in South Dakota. Native writers and activists answered with their own organizations, including the Society of American Indians, founded in 1911.

Empire abroad

In 1898 the United States fought Spain over Cuba and emerged with Puerto Rico, Guam and the Philippines, and it annexed Hawaii the same year. Filipino nationalists who had fought Spain then fought the United States in a war that lasted from 1899 to about 1902, and by many estimates at least 200,000 Filipino civilians died from fighting, hunger and disease. The Anti-Imperialist League, whose members included Twain, Carnegie and Jane Addams, argued that ruling other peoples without their consent betrayed the Declaration of Independence. Many progressives disagreed, seeing empire as a civilizing duty.

War and repression at home

The First World War brought the era to a jarring close. The federal government used its new powers to mobilize the economy and win support for the war. It also jailed critics. Debs was sentenced to ten years in prison for a 1918 speech against the war, and in 1920 he ran for president from his cell and won more than 900,000 votes. In 1919 and 1920 a Red Scare, fed by bombings and strikes, led Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer to raid radical groups and arrest thousands, many without warrants. The same years saw deadly attacks on Black communities in Chicago and other cities as Black migrants moved north.

Judging the legacy

Historians have argued about the era for decades. One influential account, from Richard Hofstadter in the 1950s, explained reform partly as the anxiety of an old middle class losing status. Robert Wiebe later described a search for order by new professionals who valued expertise. Gabriel Kolko argued that big business itself shaped regulation to protect its position. The Eighteenth Amendment, ratified in 1919, brought nationwide prohibition of alcohol, a reform that many progressives championed and that later generations judged a failure. The Nineteenth Amendment of 1920 extended the vote to women. The era left an income tax, a central bank, food safety laws, national forests, direct primaries and the belief that government should answer for the conditions of industrial life.

Worked example: one reform, two directions

Take the direct primary. In Wisconsin it took nominations away from party bosses and gave them to voters, a real expansion of democracy. In Texas or Georgia, the same device became the white primary, letting the dominant party bar Black citizens from the only contest that decided anything. The tool was identical. What differed was who counted as part of the people. That lesson reaches beyond the era. Reforms in the name of democracy should be judged not by their labels but by asking whose voice they strengthen and whose they silence, a test that applies to every generation that sets out, as the progressives did, to make its institutions answer to the public.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Which state's 1890 constitution led the way in disfranchising Black voters?
2. How did Richard Henry Pratt sum up the aim of Native boarding schools?
3. What did Wilson's administration do beginning in 1913?
4. What did the Dawes Act of 1887 do?
5. Whom did the United States fight in the Philippines from 1899 to about 1902?
6. What sentence did Debs receive for his 1918 speech against the war?
7. What did the Eighteenth Amendment, ratified in 1919, bring?
8. What did Gabriel Kolko argue about progressive regulation?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia