Skip to main content

On 22 May 1998 voters on both sides of the Irish border went to the polls on the same day to approve the same agreement. It was a rare moment in which voters across the whole island decided the same question on the same day. Getting there took seventy five years of two states developing apart, three decades of violence, and a long search for a settlement that both nationalists and unionists could accept without either side giving up who they were.

The southern state

The Irish Free State began in civil war, yet its democracy held. In 1932 de Valera's Fianna Fáil party, founded by the losers of the civil war, won an election, and the government that had defeated them handed over power peacefully. His new constitution of 1937, approved by a vote of the people, named the state Éire, or Ireland, and in its Articles 2 and 3 claimed the whole island as the national territory. Ireland stayed neutral in the Second World War. In 1949 Ireland formally declared itself a republic and left the Commonwealth.

Independence did not bring prosperity at first, and through the 1950s hundreds of thousands emigrated, until economic opening and, in 1973, membership of the European Economic Community began to change the country.

Northern Ireland under Stormont

Northern Ireland's parliament at Stormont was governed without a break by the Ulster Unionist Party from 1921 to 1972. Catholics, about a third of the population, faced discrimination in jobs and public housing. Local government elections were limited to ratepayers, which favored property owners, and electoral boundaries were drawn to protect unionist control. In Derry, the clearest case, ward boundaries let a unionist minority control a city with a nationalist majority.

In 1967 the Northern Ireland Civil Rights Association took up these grievances, borrowing methods from the American civil rights movement and demanding one person, one vote in local elections and fair allocation of housing. Violence escalated, and in August 1969, after days of rioting in Derry and deadly attacks in Belfast, British troops were deployed on the streets. The Provisional IRA emerged from a split in the republican movement, while loyalist paramilitary groups organized on the other side.

The Troubles

In August 1971 the government introduced internment without trial, used almost entirely against nationalists. On 30 January 1972, in Derry, British paratroopers shot dead thirteen people at a civil rights march, and another died later. A public inquiry reporting in 2010 found that none of those shot had posed a threat, and the British prime minister apologized. Bloody Sunday swelled IRA recruitment. That March, London suspended Stormont and imposed direct rule.

The first attempt at a settlement came at Sunningdale in 1973: a power-sharing executive of unionists and nationalists, plus a cross-border Council of Ireland. Many unionists rejected it, and in May 1974 the power-sharing executive collapsed after a loyalist general strike paralyzed the province. The killing went on, by republicans, loyalists and state forces alike. In 1981 republican prisoners demanding political status went on hunger strike; Bobby Sands was elected an MP weeks before he died, and nine others died after him.

The road to peace

In 1985 the Anglo-Irish Agreement gave the Dublin government a formal consultative role in Northern Ireland, to unionist fury. The nationalist leader John Hume held long talks with Sinn Féin's Gerry Adams to draw republicans into politics. In 1994 the IRA and the main loyalist groups declared ceasefires. Multi-party talks chaired by the American former senator George Mitchell produced an agreement on Good Friday, 10 April 1998.

At its heart is the principle of consent: Northern Ireland's status changes only if a majority of its people agree, and Britain must legislate for a united Ireland if majorities North and South so vote. It created a power-sharing assembly and executive requiring cross-community support, a North-South Ministerial Council and a British-Irish Council, and it affirmed the right of people in Northern Ireland to identify as Irish, British or both. In the referendums of 22 May 1998, about 71 percent voted yes in the North and about 94 percent in the Republic, which also replaced the territorial claim in Articles 2 and 3 with an aspiration to unity by consent. That August a breakaway republican bomb in Omagh killed 29 people, but the settlement held. The Troubles had cost about 3,500 lives.

Worked example: designing for two identities

Suppose you must draft a constitution for a region where one community wants to stay in one state and the other wants to join a neighboring one. Simple majority rule would let one side dominate the other forever. Partition again would only create new minorities. The 1998 Agreement tried a third path: settle the border question by consent and periodic choice, and meanwhile share power so that neither community governs alone. Its critics note that it can freeze division, since parties must register as unionist, nationalist or other, and the institutions have repeatedly stalled. Its defenders answer that it ended most of the killing and treated both identities as equally legitimate, giving each person the right to be Irish, British or both. Judged by whether people can live with equal dignity alongside neighbors who see the nation differently, it offers a model worth studying.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How was Ireland's 1937 constitution adopted?
2. What did Ireland do in 1949?
3. What was the clearest case of electoral discrimination in Northern Ireland's local government?
4. What happened in Derry on Bloody Sunday in 1972?
5. What brought down the Sunningdale power-sharing executive in 1974?
6. What happened to Bobby Sands in 1981?
7. What is the principle of consent in the 1998 Agreement?
8. What were the results of the referendums of 22 May 1998?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia