In 795 the annals, the year by year chronicles kept in Irish monasteries, noted the burning of a church on an island off the coast, probably Lambay near Dublin or Rathlin in the north. It was the first recorded Norse raid on Ireland. Over the next four centuries the island would absorb two waves of newcomers, first from Scandinavia and then from Anglo-Norman England, and each would end up changed by Ireland as much as it changed Ireland.
The Norse in Ireland
The early raids hit monasteries hardest, because they held treasure, food and people who could be sold as slaves. Yet the annals also show Irish kings attacking monasteries, before and after the Norse arrived, so violence against churches was not purely a foreign import. From the 840s the Norse began to winter in Ireland and build fortified bases. Several became permanent: Wexford, Waterford and Limerick all began as Norse settlements, and Dublin grew into the richest of them. Ireland had no true trading towns before. The Norse gave it its first ones, along with its first coins, minted in Dublin from about 997.
Within a few generations the Norse of these towns had converted, married into Irish families and become one more set of players in Irish politics.
Brian Boru and Clontarf
The most famous of those kings rose from a minor dynasty, the Dál Cais of the Shannon region. Brian mac Cennétig, later called Brian Boru, made himself king of Munster in 976 and then forced the powerful Uí Néill king Máel Sechnaill to submit. In 1002 he was recognized as king of Ireland, a title many had claimed but few had made real. During a visit to Armagh in 1005 a scribe recorded him in the Book of Armagh as "Emperor of the Irish", a sign of how grand his ambitions were.
In 1014 the king of Leinster and the Norse of Dublin rose against him. At the Battle of Clontarf, just north of Dublin, on Good Friday 1014, Brian was killed even though his side won. Later writers turned the battle into a national war of the Irish against the Vikings. Modern historians see it differently: Clontarf was largely a struggle among Irish kings, with Norse fighting on both sides.
Reform and invasion
In the twelfth century politics grew more ruthless. In 1166 Diarmait Mac Murchada, king of Leinster, was driven out of his kingdom by a coalition of rivals and crossed the sea to seek help from Henry II, king of England. Henry gave him permission to recruit among his barons.
The most important recruit was Richard de Clare, known as Strongbow, who was promised Diarmait's daughter Aoife in marriage and the succession to Leinster. Strongbow landed in 1170 and with his knights and archers took Waterford and Dublin. Henry II came to Ireland in 1171 largely to keep his own barons in check, and many Irish kings and bishops submitted to him. A papal letter of 1155 known as Laudabiliter was later cited to justify the whole venture; it is a papal letter said to have approved Henry's claim to Ireland, though historians still debate whether the surviving text is genuine. From then on English kings styled themselves Lords of Ireland.
Colony and Gaelic recovery
The newcomers built castles, manors, market towns and parishes. By about 1300 the colony controlled perhaps two thirds of the island, especially the fertile east and south. Then it began to shrink. A Scottish invasion under Edward Bruce from 1315 to 1318 coincided with famine, and the Black Death of 1348 to 1349 struck the towns, where settlers were concentrated, harder than the Gaelic countryside. Irish lords recovered land, and many settler families adopted the Irish language, dress, poets and law.
The colonial government's answer was the Statutes of Kilkenny of 1366, which forbade English settlers to speak Irish, use Irish law or marry into Irish families. Laws like that are good evidence of exactly what they ban: settlers were doing all three. By the late 1400s effective royal government covered only a small zone around Dublin known as the Pale.
Worked example: two accounts of Clontarf
Suppose you have two sources on the battle of 1014. The first is a short entry in a set of annals compiled not long afterward: it lists the kings and nobles who died on each side and notes that the men of Leinster and the foreigners were routed. The second is a long, stirring text called the War of the Irish against the Foreigners, written about a century later for Brian's descendants, who were then competing for the high kingship themselves. It casts Brian as the savior of Ireland from pagan invaders.
A historian asks of each source who wrote it, when and for whom. The later text had an obvious motive: glorifying the ancestor of its patrons made their own claims look stronger. The annal entry is drier, closer in time and confirms that Irish kings were among the main enemies. But on the question of who fought whom, the plainer and earlier record carries more weight. The national legend tells you about the twelfth century; the annals tell you more about the eleventh.
