Skip to main content

European visitors to Haudenosaunee country in the 1600s and 1700s were often startled by the authority of women. Jesuit missionaries complained about it, and later travelers wrote about it with curiosity or alarm. To understand why, it helps to start with the clan, the basic unit that tied households, nations and the league together.

Clans across nations

Every Haudenosaunee person belonged to a clan, inherited from the mother. Clans carried the names of animals or birds. The Mohawk and Oneida each had three clans: Turtle, Wolf and Bear. The Seneca had eight, adding clans such as Deer, Heron, Snipe, Beaver and Hawk. Members of a clan treated one another as relatives, and in most nations people were expected to marry outside their own clan.

Because the same clan names appeared in several nations, a Wolf Clan traveler could find relatives far from home. A Seneca of the Turtle Clan visiting the Mohawk could expect hospitality from Mohawk Turtle families. Clans thus stitched the separate nations together through ties of kinship that ran beneath the formal structure of the council.

The clan mother

Each clan in each nation had a senior woman, known in English as the clan mother. She was usually chosen by the women of the clan for her wisdom and character, not simply her age. Her most famous power concerned the chiefs. When a title belonging to her clan fell vacant, the clan mother chose the new chief, after consulting the women of the clan. Her choice was then confirmed by the clan, the nation and finally the Grand Council at a Condolence ceremony.

She could also take the title away. If a chief acted against the people's welfare, the clan mother would warn him, and if he ignored repeated warnings, she could remove him from office. In the language of the Great Law, she took back the antlers that marked his office, which is why removal is sometimes called "knocking off the horns." Each chief also had a partner among the women, and the clan mother kept watch over how the title was used.

Fields, food and war

Women's political influence rested on economic power. Women owned the fields and controlled the food stores, and households passed through the female line. A war party needed corn, dried food and moccasins for the trail, and these came from women. Several accounts describe women using this control to influence decisions about war, whether by supplying a war party or by withholding support from it.

Women also held a strong voice in deciding the fate of captives. After a battle, captives might be killed, but many were adopted into families to replace members who had died. In many cases women decided whether a captive would be adopted, and an adopted person could take the name and place of the dead relative. Women also spoke in councils of their own and could send speakers to men's councils.

The suffragists' discovery

In the nineteenth century, some American women's rights campaigners looked to the Haudenosaunee as proof that women's political power was not unnatural. Matilda Joslyn Gage, a leading suffragist, was adopted into the Wolf Clan of the Mohawk in 1893, and wrote admiringly about Haudenosaunee women in Woman, Church and State, published the same year. Elizabeth Cady Stanton also praised the clan mothers. The historian Sally Roesch Wagner has argued that the example of Haudenosaunee neighbors in upstate New York, where the 1848 Seneca Falls convention met, helped inspire these women to imagine a different arrangement of power.

Other historians urge caution. They note that the suffragists sometimes idealized a society they knew mostly through books and brief visits, and that most of their ideas had sources in Quaker practice, abolitionism and Enlightenment arguments about rights. Haudenosaunee women's authority was also different from voting. Chiefs were men, men spoke for the nations in the Grand Council, and the balance between the sexes was a balance of separate spheres rather than a single shared ballot. A fair conclusion is that the example was real and admired, but it was one influence among several on the suffrage movement.

Worked example: removing a chief

Imagine a chief of the Bear Clan who has begun accepting gifts from land speculators and agreeing to sales without consulting his people. Word reaches the clan mother. She first speaks to him privately, reminding him of his duty to the coming generations. He ignores her. She returns, this time with another woman of the clan, and repeats the warning. Again nothing changes.

On the third occasion, the warning is delivered with the support of the clan's men. When he still refuses to change course, the clan mother announces that she is taking back the title. The antlers are removed, and the name goes back to the clan. She then consults the clan's women about who should hold it next and presents her choice to the nation. The new man will be raised through the Condolence ceremony and will take the very same title. The point of the process is not punishment for its own sake. It keeps the office tied to the clan and its women, so that the person holding the name answers to those who gave it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Which clans did the Mohawk and Oneida each have?
2. How did clans link the separate nations?
3. Who chose a new chief when a title fell vacant?
4. What could a clan mother do to a chief who ignored warnings?
5. What was the basis of women's economic power?
6. Who often decided whether a captive was adopted?
7. Which suffragist was adopted into the Mohawk Wolf Clan?
8. What did Sally Roesch Wagner argue about the suffragists?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia