Skip to main content

From Shewa to the throne

Menelik, king of the southern province of Shewa, had spent his youth as a captive at Tewodros's court before escaping home. Patient and shrewd, he built up his army with firearms bought from European traders and waited. When Yohannes died in 1889, Menelik was crowned emperor. His wife, Empress Taytu Betul, was a formidable political figure in her own right. In 1886 the couple had founded a new settlement near hot springs in the center of the country, known in Oromo as Finfinne; Taytu named it Addis Ababa, "new flower," and it became the permanent capital.

Southward expansion

In the 1880s and 1890s Menelik's armies conquered vast territories to the south, east and west: the Muslim city-state of Harar in 1887, the Arsi Oromo after years of fierce resistance, the kingdom of Wolaita in 1894, the kingdom of Kaffa in 1897 and many more. By 1900 the empire had roughly doubled in size and taken on something like its modern borders.

The conquest reshaped southern society. Soldiers and settlers from the north, called neftegna, "gun carriers," received land and authority, and local farmers were assigned to support them. Under this gabbar system, conquered peasants owed labor and tribute to the soldiers placed over them. Enslaved captives from the south were traded and held in large numbers. Southern communities lost much of their land and self-rule. Outcomes varied. Some rulers, such as Abba Jifar II of the Oromo kingdom of Jimma, submitted early and kept their thrones as tribute-paying vassals for decades, while peoples who fought on, like the Arsi and the Wolaita, suffered heavy killing, enslavement and the loss of their land.

How to describe this expansion remains one of the most divisive questions in Ethiopian politics. One view holds that Menelik reunited lands that medieval Christian kings had once ruled and built a state strong enough to stay free. Another holds that it was a conquest much like European colonialism, carried out at the same time and with similar violence and dispossession. Many historians accept parts of both: it was an African empire building itself, by force, in competition with European empires closing in.

The treaty and the trap

Italy, holding the Red Sea coast, hoped to extend its power inland. In May 1889 Menelik signed the Treaty of Wuchale with Italy, gaining recognition and arms in exchange for land in the north. The trouble lay in Article 17. The Amharic text said Menelik could use Italy's government for his dealings with other powers if he wished. The Italian text said he must, and on that basis Italy told Europe that Ethiopia was its protectorate. In 1890 Italy also proclaimed its coastal holdings a colony named Eritrea. Taytu was among the fiercest critics of the treaty, and Menelik soon rejected Italy's reading of it.

Adwa and after

Italy invaded from Eritrea. On 1 March 1896, near the town of Adwa, Menelik's army of about 100,000 met an Italian force of some 17,000, including Eritrean soldiers, under General Oreste Baratieri. The Italians, advancing in separate columns over unfamiliar terrain, were overwhelmed and lost several thousand dead. Taytu commanded her own troops during the campaign. The Treaty of Addis Ababa in October recognized Ethiopia's full independence, but Italy kept Eritrea, a division that would shape the region for a century.

Menelik had prepared for the war shrewdly, playing European rivals against each other and buying modern rifles from French, Russian and other suppliers even while Italy tried to block his imports. After the victory he brought in new technologies. A railway from the French port of Djibouti, begun in 1897, reached Addis Ababa in 1917. Telephone and telegraph lines, a bank, a postal service and the first government school of modern type, opened in 1908, followed. Menelik suffered a series of strokes from about 1906 and died in 1913.

Worked example: one battle, many meanings

Ask what Adwa means and the answer depends on where you stand. For Ethiopians across the country it is a national holiday, a victory in which people of many regions fought together. Far beyond Ethiopia, it became a symbol for Africans and people of African descent that European conquest was not inevitable. Churches in South Africa and later movements in the Caribbean took the name "Ethiopian" as a badge of independence and pride.

For some communities in the south, however, Adwa came in the middle of their own conquest by the same emperor. Among the Arsi Oromo, for example, memories of the mass mutilations at Anole in the 1880s, carried out by Menelik's forces, sit beside the story of Adwa. A monument to the Anole victims was raised in 2014, and its meaning is still argued over. Both memories are real. A mature history can honor a victory over a colonial invader while also acknowledging that the victors had conquered others. Holding the two together is harder than choosing one, and it is closer to the truth. It also explains why arguments over statues, street names and school textbooks about Menelik remain so heated in Ethiopia today.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who was Taytu Betul?
2. What does Addis Ababa mean?
3. By about how much did Menelik's conquests enlarge the empire?
4. Under the gabbar system, what did conquered peasants owe?
5. How do critics describe Menelik's expansion?
6. What did Article 17 of Wuchale say in Italian?
7. What did Italy keep after Adwa?
8. What was Taytu's role in the Adwa campaign?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia