The new republic faced enemies on every side. Royalists and Irish Confederates held most of Ireland, and the Scots, who had not been consulted about the king's death, proclaimed his son king as Charles II. At home the Levellers denounced the Rump as a new tyranny, and in May 1649 a Leveller mutiny in the army was crushed at Burford in Oxfordshire, where three soldiers were shot in the churchyard.
Conquering the other kingdoms
Cromwell spent 1649 and 1650 in Ireland, where his campaign and the land confiscations that followed left a bitter memory that lasted for centuries. He then turned on Scotland. Charles II had accepted the Covenants as the price of Scottish support, and on 1 January 1651 he was crowned king of Scots at Scone. Cromwell had already beaten a larger Scottish army at Dunbar in September 1650. When Charles led an army into England, it was destroyed at Worcester on 3 September 1651, exactly a year after Dunbar. The young king escaped, hid in an oak tree at Boscobel in Shropshire and after six weeks on the run reached France. For the first time, England, Scotland and Ireland were all governed from London as one state.
The Rump and the saints
The Rump passed a Navigation Act in 1651 and fought a naval war against the Dutch, but it was slow to hold new elections or reform the law, and the army grew impatient. On 20 April 1653 Cromwell entered the chamber with musketeers and dissolved it. In its place came an assembly of about 140 godly men nominated by the army's leaders, often called Barebone's Parliament after one member, a London leather seller named Praise God Barbon. Its radicals proposed abolishing tithes, the payments that supported the parish clergy, and replacing the old courts. Moderates feared for property, and in December 1653 they voted to hand power back to Cromwell.
The Instrument of Government
The army's officers had a constitution ready. The Instrument of Government of December 1653 was a written constitution, the first that England ever had. It made Cromwell Lord Protector for life, governing with a Council of State and a single chamber parliament to be elected at least every three years, with seats for Scotland and Ireland. It provided for a standing army, and it promised freedom of worship to those who professed faith in God by Jesus Christ, though not to Catholics or to those who used the old prayer book. Cromwell repeatedly tried to share power with parliaments, and repeatedly dissolved them when they challenged the army or religious liberty.
After a failed royalist rising in March 1655, led by John Penruddock in Wiltshire, Cromwell divided England and Wales into districts, each under a Major General charged with security and the reformation of manners: suppressing alehouses, horse races and other occasions of disorder. The scheme was paid for by a decimation tax, a levy of one tenth on the income of former royalists. It lasted little more than a year.
Power at home and abroad
The Protectorate pursued an ambitious foreign policy. A naval expedition against Spain in the Caribbean failed at Hispaniola but captured Jamaica in 1655, which became a center of the English slave plantation system. In the same years Cromwell welcomed the petition of the Amsterdam rabbi Menasseh ben Israel for Jews to be allowed to live in England, from which they had been expelled in 1290. A conference at Whitehall in December 1655 ended without a decision, but Jews were tolerated in practice from 1656, holding private worship and buying a burial ground, without any formal law of readmission.
In 1657 Parliament offered Cromwell the crown in a new constitution called the Humble Petition and Advice. After weeks of hesitation he refused the title of king, partly because many officers opposed it, but accepted the rest, including the right to name his successor and a second chamber. He died on 3 September 1658, the anniversary of Dunbar and Worcester.
Worked example: the trial of James Nayler
In October 1656 a Quaker preacher, James Nayler, rode into Bristol in the rain on a horse while followers sang and spread their garments before him, a re-enactment of Christ's entry into Jerusalem. Parliament, not a court, took up the case. After weeks of debate members convicted him of horrid blasphemy. A motion to put him to death failed by 96 votes to 82. Instead he was whipped through London, his tongue was bored through with a hot iron, and his forehead was branded with the letter B.
Apply the ideas from this level. The Instrument promised toleration, yet it did not say where toleration ended, and Parliament claimed the power to punish on its own judgment, without a law defining the crime. Cromwell wrote to ask on what authority Parliament had acted, and the case helped persuade many members that a second chamber was needed to check the Commons. Nayler showed that a regime founded in the name of liberty of conscience could still inflict savage punishment, and that protecting rights needs clear limits on every holder of power, an assembly as much as a king.
