Skip to main content

A slump in one country is a recession. The Great Depression earned its name because it spread almost everywhere at once, from Chicago to Vienna, from Buenos Aires to Tokyo. It traveled along three channels: trade, which shrank as countries closed their markets; finance, as banks in one country pulled money from another; and the gold standard, which tied currencies together so that one country's crisis became its neighbors' problem.

Commodity exporters hit first

Countries that sold food and raw materials suffered early. As demand from industrial countries fell, prices for their exports collapsed. Between 1929 and 1932 the world prices of many basic commodities, including wheat, coffee, rubber and silk, fell by half or more. A country like Brazil, which earned most of its foreign money from coffee, or Australia and Argentina, which depended on wheat and wool, suddenly could not pay its foreign debts. Several Latin American governments stopped payments on their bonds in the early 1930s, and armed revolts toppled governments in Argentina and Brazil in 1930.

Tariff walls

In June 1930 President Hoover signed the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act, which raised American import duties on thousands of goods. More than a thousand economists had signed a petition asking him to veto it. Other countries answered with their own barriers. Canada, the largest American trading partner, raised duties on American goods; European countries added tariffs and import quotas. In 1932 Britain abandoned its long tradition of free trade, and at the Ottawa conference that year it agreed to imperial preference, lower duties for trade within the British Empire.

Economists still debate how much Smoot-Hawley itself caused. Trade fell mostly because incomes fell. But the tariff war poisoned cooperation at the moment when countries most needed to work together.

The financial crisis of 1931

The most dangerous phase came in 1931. In May the Creditanstalt, Austria's largest bank, announced huge losses. The Austrian government stepped in, but foreign lenders, frightened, began pulling money out of central Europe. The panic spread to Hungary and then to Germany, whose banks owed large sums to foreign lenders on short terms.

In June, to relieve the pressure, Hoover proposed a one-year moratorium suspending reparations and war debt payments between governments. France, which counted on reparations, delayed its approval for weeks, and the delay helped drain confidence. In July one of Germany's biggest banks, the Danat Bank, failed, and the German government closed all banks for several days and imposed controls on the movement of money abroad.

Britain leaves gold

The run then moved to London. Foreign holders of pounds feared Britain could not keep its gold promise, and the Bank of England lost reserves quickly. In August the Labour government split over cuts to unemployment benefits, and a new National Government took office. Even so, on September 21, 1931, Britain suspended the gold standard, and the pound soon lost about a quarter of its value against the dollar.

Britain's departure was a shock, because the pound had been the center of world finance for a century. Many countries, especially those that traded heavily with Britain, followed within months. They formed a loose "sterling area." The United States left gold in 1933. A "gold bloc" led by France, with Belgium, the Netherlands, Switzerland and others, held on to gold until 1935 or 1936, and these countries suffered a long slump while others began to recover.

Failed attempts at cooperation

Leaders did try to work together. At Lausanne in 1932 European governments agreed to end German reparations almost entirely, although the United States refused to cancel war debts in return, and most debtor countries soon stopped paying anyway. In 1933 representatives of sixty-six countries met at the World Economic Conference in London to stabilize currencies and lower tariffs. Franklin Roosevelt, the new American president, rejected a plan to fix exchange rates, saying American recovery came first, and the conference broke up with nothing achieved.

The economic historian Charles Kindleberger later argued that the Depression was so deep because no country would act as a stabilizer. Britain was willing but no longer able; the United States was able but not yet willing.

Worked example: the shrinking spiral of world trade

Kindleberger drew a famous chart of the value of world imports, month by month. He plotted each month as a point around a circle, so each year formed a ring. The rings spiral inward: January 1929 lies on the outer edge, and January 1933 lies near the center. Over those four years the value of world trade fell by about two-thirds.

Part of the fall reflects lower prices; the volume of goods fell by roughly a quarter. Each step made sense to the country taking it. A farmer in France, protected by a quota, kept his market. A worker in Detroit was told the tariff protected his job. But every barrier cut someone else's exports, which cut their income and their purchases from abroad. The spiral shows how choices that look sensible inside one country can, together, shrink the pie for everyone.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What happened to many commodity prices between 1929 and 1932?
2. What did the Smoot-Hawley Act of 1930 do?
3. What did Britain agree to at Ottawa in 1932?
4. What set off the European financial panic of 1931?
5. What did Hoover propose in June 1931?
6. When did Britain suspend the gold standard?
7. Which countries made up the gold bloc that held on to gold into the mid 1930s?
8. What did Roosevelt reject at the London conference of 1933?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia