Skip to main content

Borrowing lets a person use tomorrow's income today, and interest is what that convenience costs. It is one of the oldest ideas in economic life and one of the most fought over: condemned by philosophers and prophets for centuries, then made the foundation of modern finance.

Why lenders charge interest

A lender who hands over money gives up three things. First, the use of the money in the meantime: it could have been spent or invested elsewhere. Second, certainty: some borrowers will not repay. Third, value: if prices rise, the money that comes back buys less. Interest compensates for all three, which is why riskier borrowers are usually charged higher interest rates. A government with a long record of paying its debts borrows more cheaply than a new business, and a business more cheaply than a stranger with no credit history.

Interest on interest

The real force of interest shows over time. With simple interest, a lender earns a fixed amount each year on the original sum. With compound interest, interest is charged on past interest as well as on the original sum, so the total grows faster and faster. At low rates over a few years the difference is small. Over decades, or at high rates, it becomes enormous. A handy shortcut is the rule of 72: divide 72 by the yearly interest rate to estimate how many years a sum takes to double. At 6 percent, money doubles in about twelve years; at 24 percent, a common credit card rate, an unpaid debt doubles in about three.

Benjamin Franklin turned this into a public experiment. In his will of 1790 he left 1,000 pounds each to Boston and Philadelphia, to be lent at interest to young married craftsmen. Part of each fund was to be spent on public works after a hundred years, and the rest left to grow for another hundred. By the time the funds were wound up around 1990, Boston's had grown to several million dollars. Franklin wanted to show what patience and compounding could do for a city.

The long war on usury

For most of history, charging interest at all was morally suspect. Aristotle argued that making money breed more money was the most unnatural way to get wealth; in the Politics he wrote that money was meant for exchange, and that of all modes of getting wealth this "is the most unnatural." The Hebrew Bible forbade charging interest to a fellow Israelite, though it allowed interest from foreigners. Medieval Christian authorities condemned usury, which once meant any interest on a loan and now usually means excessive interest. Islamic law prohibits riba, generally understood as interest, and Islamic banks avoid interest by sharing profits or charging an agreed markup on goods they buy and resell.

These bans did not stop lending; they shaped it. Lenders disguised interest as fees, penalties or sales. Over time attitudes shifted. The Protestant reformer John Calvin accepted moderate interest on business loans, and an English law of 1571 allowed interest up to 10 percent a year. The old moral worry survived in a new form: not whether interest is permitted, but when it becomes exploitation.

Both sides of the old debate have a point. Defenders of interest say it is a fair price for time and risk, and that without it few people would lend, so those with the least would lose access to credit altogether. Critics say interest tends to flow from those who have less to those who have more, and that a person in desperate need is in no position to bargain. Modern societies mostly split the difference, allowing interest but capping or policing the extremes.

Comparing the true cost

A loan's cost can be hidden in many ways: fees, odd time periods, add-ons. To make comparison possible, the United States passed the Truth in Lending Act in 1968. The annual percentage rate, or APR, expresses a loan's yearly cost, including most fees, as a single percentage, so that borrowers can compare offers on a common scale. A fee of 15 for every 100 borrowed for two weeks sounds small; expressed as an APR, it is close to 400 percent. Similar disclosure rules now exist in many countries. Disclosure does not guarantee wise choices, but it makes the price of time visible.

Worked example: two ways to buy a sofa

Jonah wants a sofa that costs 1,200. The store offers "no payments for a year." Reading the fine print, he finds the plan uses deferred interest: if any balance remains after twelve months, interest at 27 percent is charged all the way back to the purchase date. His other option is a credit union loan at 9 percent APR over two years. Using the rule of 72, Jonah sees that at 27 percent an unpaid balance roughly doubles in under three years. If he can certainly clear the sofa within the year, the store plan costs nothing. If there is any doubt, a single missed final payment would cost him a full year of back interest, and the credit union loan is the safer, plainly priced choice. Comparing APRs, and the conditions behind them, turns a vague feeling into a clear decision.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Which borrower is usually charged a higher interest rate?
2. What is compound interest?
3. What does the rule of 72 estimate?
4. Why did Aristotle condemn lending at interest?
5. What does the word usury now usually mean?
6. How do Islamic banks avoid charging interest?
7. What does the annual percentage rate (APR) express?
8. What did an English law of 1571 allow?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia