Skip to main content

When a problem resists solution for centuries, some thinkers conclude that one of its assumptions must be wrong. In the debate over consciousness, two bold views take opposite assumptions and throw them out. One says that phenomenal consciousness, as philosophers describe it, does not exist. The other says it exists everywhere.

Dennett and the end of the inner theater

Daniel Dennett, who taught at Tufts University for decades and died in 2024, spent his career attacking what he saw as a picture that keeps confusing us. In Consciousness Explained (1991) he called it the Cartesian theater: the idea that there is one central place in the brain where everything comes together and is shown to an inner viewer. There is no such place, Dennett argued, and no little viewer. Instead, many processes in the brain work in parallel, each producing partial interpretations, or drafts, of what is happening. He called this the multiple drafts model. Some drafts win influence over speech, memory and action. That influence, not a show on an inner screen, is what being conscious amounts to.

Dennett proposed a method he called heterophenomenology: treat people's reports as data about how things seem to them, without assuming those reports are accurate. A scientist should take seriously that you say the world looks rich and detailed, just as an anthropologist takes seriously what a people believes about its gods, without thereby accepting that the belief is true. In a 1988 essay, Dennett argued that qualia, defined as private, intrinsic and indescribable inner properties, do not exist at all.

Illusionism

The British philosopher Keith Frankish gave this line of thought a name in 2016: illusionism. It holds that phenomenal consciousness is an illusion created by introspection. Our brains represent their own states as having special qualitative properties, a glow of feeling over and above the processing. They do not really have such properties. Illusionists stress that they do not deny that people see, hurt or enjoy things. They deny that there is an extra, inner quality that resists physical explanation. The real task, on their view, is the illusion problem: explaining why brains represent themselves this way.

Critics find this self-defeating. An illusion is a case of things seeming a certain way when they are not. But seeming is itself an experience, so an illusion of experience already involves experience. If it seems to me that I am in pain, that seeming is the pain. The British philosopher Galen Strawson called the denial of consciousness the silliest idea anyone has ever held. Illusionists reply that the word seems can describe information in a system without any extra feeling.

Panpsychism

At the other extreme, panpsychism holds that consciousness is a basic and widespread feature of the physical world, present in some extremely simple form even in fundamental particles. A particle does not think or worry. The claim is only that the most basic physical things have some trace of inner being, and that human experience is built from it.

The modern case starts from a point made by Bertrand Russell in The Analysis of Matter (1927) and by the astronomer Arthur Eddington the following year. Physics describes what matter does, its structure and relations, but not what matter is in itself. Mass is defined by how things accelerate and attract; charge by how things repel and attract. What underlies these dispositions physics does not say. Perhaps, panpsychists suggest, the inner nature of matter is experiential. This view is sometimes called Russellian monism. It promises to place consciousness inside physics instead of floating beside it, and to avoid the puzzle of experience appearing suddenly from wholly unexperiencing parts.

Its central difficulty is the combination problem: how could tiny experiences of particles combine into one unified human mind? William James put an early form of the problem in 1890: tell each of twelve men one word of a sentence and stand them in a row, and "nowhere will there be a consciousness of the whole sentence." Panpsychists have proposed answers, but none is widely accepted. Critics add that there is no evidence of experience in particles, and that the view may only relocate the mystery.

Worked example: the card at the edge of sight

Look straight ahead at a fixed point. Have a friend hold a playing card at the far edge of your vision, then bring it slowly toward the center. For a surprisingly long way, you probably cannot tell its color or value. Your eye has few color-sensitive cells and poor detail away from the center. Yet your visual world does not feel gray and blurry at the edges. It feels evenly rich, colored and detailed.

An illusionist uses this as a model. Your brain represents the visual field as uniformly rich, but the representation outruns the facts, because the eyes keep darting and the brain fills in. If introspection can be wrong about this, perhaps it is wrong about the special glow of experience too. A critic replies that the card shows only that we can be wrong about the contents of experience, not that experience itself is missing. A panpsychist would add that the existence of any experience, accurate or not, is the deep fact to explain. The same simple test supports very different conclusions.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Dennett mean by the Cartesian theater?
2. What is heterophenomenology?
3. What does illusionism hold?
4. What is the illusion problem, according to illusionists?
5. What is the main objection to illusionism?
6. What does panpsychism hold?
7. What point did Russell and Eddington make about physics?
8. What is the combination problem?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia