The armistice of January 1871 ended the fighting but not the crisis. In six weeks a newly elected assembly, dominated by men who distrusted Paris, made a series of decisions that turned anger into open revolt. The decisive day came on 18 March, at dawn, on the hill of Montmartre.
A monarchist assembly
The armistice required France to elect an assembly that could make peace. In the elections of 8 February 1871 the countryside voted for peace and for local notables, many of them monarchists. Around four hundred of the new deputies supported a return to monarchy, though they were split between rival royal families. Paris, by contrast, elected republicans and radicals, including Victor Hugo and the socialist Louis Blanc.
The Assembly met in Bordeaux and chose as head of the executive Adolphe Thiers, a veteran politician of seventy-three. Thiers had been a minister under the July Monarchy and had written a famous history of the first French Revolution. He was a conservative who had come to accept a republic as the regime that divided France least. In 1834 he had helped crush risings in Lyon and Paris, and Parisian radicals had not forgotten it.
The peace and its humiliations
Thiers negotiated preliminary terms that the Assembly approved on 1 March. France gave up Alsace and much of Lorraine and agreed to pay an indemnity of five billion francs, with German troops occupying parts of the country until it was paid. On 1 March German soldiers held a brief victory parade in western Paris. The streets were empty and shops closed in protest.
Three decisions
Then the Assembly took three steps that hit Paris directly. First, it moved its seat to Versailles, the old royal town, rather than to the capital. Second, it ended the wartime suspension on commercial debts, requiring bills that had been put off since the summer to be paid almost at once, which threatened shopkeepers and small manufacturers with ruin. Third, it ended the guardsmen's daily pay except for those who could prove need. The suspension of rent payments was not renewed either, and three quarters of unpaid rent hung over many households.
Meanwhile the National Guard organized itself. Battalions elected delegates to a Republican Federation of the National Guard, led by a Central Committee. From this federation the insurgents later took their name, the fédérés. Guardsmen also moved about four hundred cannons, many paid for by public subscription during the siege, to parks in Montmartre and Belleville, so that the Germans would not take them during their parade.
Dawn at Montmartre
Thiers decided that the government could not rule while an armed militia held the capital's artillery. Before dawn on 18 March, regular troops climbed Montmartre to seize the cannons. They took the guns easily, but nobody had brought enough horses to haul them away. As the morning went on, crowds gathered, many of them women, among them the schoolteacher Louise Michel. They surrounded the soldiers, offered them food and drink and urged them not to fire.
General Claude Lecomte ordered his men to fire on the crowd. His soldiers refused and turned their rifle butts up, and many joined the people. Lecomte was seized. Later that afternoon he and Clément Thomas, a former commander of the National Guard who was recognized in civilian clothes, were shot by a mob of soldiers and guardsmen in a garden on the rue des Rosiers. Members of the local committee tried and failed to stop the killing.
Thiers reacted with a plan he had proposed in earlier crises: he withdrew the government and the army from Paris to Versailles, intending to return in force. By night the Central Committee of the National Guard sat in the Hôtel de Ville, almost surprised to find itself in charge of a great city.
Worked example: whose revolution?
Ask who made 18 March. No party planned it. The Central Committee had not ordered a rising, and the best known revolutionary, Auguste Blanqui, had been arrested in the provinces the day before. The day was decided by a failure of logistics, a crowd of neighbors and soldiers who would not shoot.
Now weigh the motives. The Assembly's three decisions touched money, work and pride: debts falling due, wages ending and a capital passed over for a royal town. The cannons touched patriotism, since Parisians saw them as their own, bought to fight the Germans. The monarchist majority touched politics, since many feared the republic itself would be dismantled.
Finally, consider Thiers's choice. Withdrawing the army avoided a battle in the streets that day and kept troops away from further fraternizing. It also handed Paris to the insurgents and made a later reconquest likely to be bloody. Historians still weigh whether a negotiated settlement was possible in the days that followed, when the elected mayors of the Paris districts tried to mediate and failed. One of them was the young mayor of Montmartre, Georges Clemenceau, who had tried that very afternoon to save Lecomte and arrived too late. Decades later he would lead France through another war with Germany.
