The planner and the writer
For four decades Robert Moses, who never won an election, shaped New York more than any mayor. Holding many appointed posts at once, he built parks, beaches, bridges, public housing and hundreds of kilometers of highway, often clearing whole neighborhoods in the process. His most famous opponent was a writer with no official title at all. In The Death and Life of Great American Cities, published in 1961, Jane Jacobs attacked the planners of her day. Jacobs argued that busy, mixed-use streets keep neighborhoods safe through the natural watchfulness of people who live, shop and work there. She praised short blocks, old buildings alongside new ones, and the untidy mix that planners called blight.
Jacobs and her neighbors helped stop a road through Washington Square Park and then Moses's planned Lower Manhattan Expressway, which would have cut through what are now SoHo and Little Italy. Her victory reshaped planning in many countries, with new respect for neighborhoods and new tools for residents to resist large projects.
Critics have noted an irony. Greenwich Village, which Jacobs celebrated, became one of the most expensive places in America, partly because so little new housing was allowed. The tools her generation built to stop highways are now often used to block new housing. Defenders of Jacobs reply that she favored density and diversity, and would likely have opposed rules that freeze a neighborhood in place.
Who shows up
Many planning decisions are made after public hearings, which sound democratic. But who speaks? Katherine Levine Einstein, David Glick and Maxwell Palmer studied hundreds of planning and zoning meetings in Massachusetts. They found that people who speak at planning meetings tend to be older homeowners who oppose new housing more than the public does. Renters, younger people and those who might live in a building not yet built were rarely heard. The authors did not claim the speakers acted in bad faith; they showed that a process open to all can still give some voices far more weight than others.
Which level of government?
Housing decisions face a mismatch of scale. The costs of a new building, such as construction noise and more traffic, fall on immediate neighbors. The benefits, such as lower rents across a region and more workers near jobs, spread widely and fall partly on people who do not yet live there to vote. For that reason, state or national governments sometimes override local zoning, because the benefits of new housing spread beyond one town. California, for instance, passed a 2021 law allowing most lots zoned for one house to hold two homes or be split in two. Japan's national zoning, discussed earlier, is a long-standing example.
The case against such overrides is serious too. Local government is where citizens can most easily take part, and local knowledge of drainage, schools or traffic can be lost in uniform rules. If distant officials decide what is built on every street, people may feel that self-government has been hollowed out. The challenge is to keep local voice while preventing any one town from closing its doors to everyone else.
A right to the city
In 1968 the French philosopher Henri Lefebvre argued that city dwellers have a claim to shape urban life, not merely to buy space in it. His phrase, the right to the city, has been taken up by tenant groups and social movements worldwide. International law approaches the question more concretely. The United Nations committee that oversees economic and social rights described, in 1991, what makes housing adequate. The UN's account of adequate housing includes security of tenure and affordability, not only a roof, along with habitability, access to services and a location within reach of work and schools.
These ideas connect housing to basic human dignity. A person who can be removed at will, or who must spend most of each day traveling to work, or who cannot find any home at all, has less freedom to take part in the life of the community. The disagreements in this subject are about means, not the end: markets or public building, local or national control, protection for current residents or room for newcomers. Very few people dispute the end.
Worked example: the hearing on Elm Street
A town council holds a hearing on rezoning six blocks near a rail station to allow four-story buildings. Thirty people speak. Twenty-six own homes nearby, and most oppose the plan, citing parking and the character of the street. Few renters attend, and nobody speaks for the nurses and teachers who work in the town but live an hour away.
Apply the level. The Einstein, Glick and Palmer findings suggest the room does not mirror the town, so the council might also survey residents, hold meetings at other hours or online, and invite workers who commute in. Jacobs would ask whether the plan keeps streets lively and mixed. The homevoter idea helps explain the owners' worry without dismissing it. And if the town refuses, a state law might eventually decide for it. A council that weighs all of these voices, and explains openly how it chose, is doing what local democracy is supposed to do.
