Troubles of succession
The succession wars of earlier centuries returned in the late 1600s, when rival princes and chiefs fought over the throne and the capital suffered. Tradition says the crisis ended under Oba Ewuakpe, around 1700, and that from around 1700 the rule was that the oba's eldest son should succeed. The new rule did not end all conflict, since a disputed eldest son could still face rivals, but it gave the dynasty firmer ground. The eighteenth century under kings such as Akenzua I is remembered as a time of renewed wealth and royal power.
New pressures
In the nineteenth century the world around Benin changed. Britain abolished its slave trade in 1807 and its navy patrolled the coast. European factories demanded palm oil for soap, candles and machine grease, and the creeks of the Niger delta filled with British traders. Benin sold palm oil and other produce, but its kings kept tight control. They closed trade routes, demanded tolls and suspended trade when terms displeased them.
Britain was building an empire in the region. It declared a protectorate over the coast and its rivers in the 1880s and 1890s, later named the Niger Coast Protectorate. African traders who stood in its way were broken. In 1894 British forces destroyed the stronghold of Nana Olomu, a powerful Itsekiri merchant who controlled trade on the Benin River, and sent him into exile.
In 1892 a British vice consul, Henry Gallwey, visited Benin City. Henry Gallwey obtained a treaty in 1892 that Britain read as accepting its protection and allowing free trade. Edo accounts say the oba, Ovonramwen, never understood or agreed to what the document claimed. British officials later accused him of breaking it by restricting trade.
British writers also stressed human sacrifice at Benin. Sacrifice of people did take place at some royal rites, as it had in many kingdoms around the world, and Edo sources do not deny it. But British accounts magnified it, especially after 1897, to present the conquest as a rescue rather than a seizure.
The Phillips mission
In November 1896 James Phillips, acting consul general of the protectorate, wrote to the Foreign Office in London. Phillips's letter of November 1896 proposed deposing the oba, and suggested that ivory in the palace could pay for an expedition. Before an answer came, he set out for Benin City with a small party of British officials and traders and some two hundred African carriers, without an armed escort.
Messengers from the oba asked him to wait. The oba could not receive strangers during the Ague festival, a time of royal seclusion, and the court warned that a visit then would be dangerous. Phillips pressed on. On 4 January 1897, near the village of Ugbine, warriors attacked the column. Only two of the nine Europeans in Phillips's party survived, and many of the African carriers were also killed. Edo accounts say chiefs ordered the attack against the oba's wishes, fearing that the visit was an invasion in disguise; the exact chain of command remains uncertain.
The expedition
Britain responded within weeks. Admiral Sir Harry Rawson commanded the 1897 expedition, a force of about 1,200 marines and sailors, supported by protectorate soldiers and many African carriers, armed with machine guns and rockets. After days of fighting through the forest, the troops entered Benin City on 18 February 1897. A few days later fire swept through much of the city. Soldiers stripped the palace and royal shrines of thousands of brass, ivory and wooden objects.
Ovonramwen fled into the countryside and surrendered in August. At a trial run by the British consul general, he was condemned for the killings, though the court accepted that he had not ordered them. The British exiled Ovonramwen to Calabar, a town on the coast to the east, where he died in 1914. Several chiefs were executed or killed themselves, and the kingdom passed under British rule.
Worked example: punishment or planned conquest?
British officials called the expedition a punishment for the killing of Phillips. Many historians see it as a conquest that was already being prepared. How can the question be tested?
Evidence for planned conquest: Phillips's letter shows that removing the oba was already proposed before the ambush. Benin's control of trade had long frustrated British merchants, and the destruction of Nana Olomu two years earlier shows a pattern of removing African powers that blocked trade. The speed of the response suggests that plans and forces were close at hand. In 2020 the archaeologist Dan Hicks argued that such punitive raids were a form of colonial warfare in which looting was not an accident but part of the purpose.
Evidence on the other side: London had not approved Phillips's plan, and the killing of an unarmed party gave the expedition a genuine cause in British eyes. The attack shocked British opinion and shaped the decision to act.
A balanced reading is that the ambush supplied the reason, while British ambitions supplied the readiness. Both the deaths at Ugbine and the burning of a capital were real losses of human life, and neither erases the other.
