Skip to main content

When Abd al-Rahman III became emir in 912, his state was shrinking to a single city. Over the next half century he and his son turned it into the most powerful realm in western Europe, with a capital that impressed visitors from Constantinople and Germany. Within another seventy years it had collapsed so completely that its leading citizens voted it out of existence. Few states have risen and fallen so fast.

Rebuilding a state

Abd al-Rahman III spent his first years retaking rebel fortresses one by one, including Bobastro in 928. He then took the title of caliph in 929, partly to answer the Fatimids, a rival dynasty in North Africa that had already claimed it. He gained income from trade and a tightly managed tax system, and he built a standing army and a navy that controlled the western Mediterranean coast.

The palace city

In 936 the caliph began Madinat al-Zahra, a palace city a few kilometers west of Córdoba. It held government offices, a mosque, gardens, workshops and reception halls on terraces cut into a hillside. Later writers described a hall with a basin of quicksilver that threw moving light across the walls when it was stirred, an account that cannot be checked. What is certain is the end. Madinat al-Zahra was sacked in 1010, during the civil war, and its stones were carried off for other buildings. Excavation began in 1911, and in 2018 the site was named a World Heritage Site.

Diplomacy and learning

Ambassadors came to Córdoba from Byzantium and from Christian kings in the north. The German ruler Otto I sent the monk John of Gorze, who waited about three years for an audience in the 950s while the two courts argued over the wording of his letters. A key figure in this diplomacy was Hasdai ibn Shaprut, a Jewish physician who served as the caliph's adviser and customs chief. When the Byzantine emperor sent a Greek manuscript of Dioscorides' book on medicinal plants, Hasdai worked with a Greek monk named Nicholas to put it into Arabic. Hasdai also supported Hebrew scholars and poets, helping to begin a flowering of Jewish learning in al-Andalus.

Medicine prospered too. Al-Zahrawi, a physician of Córdoba who died around 1013, wrote a medical encyclopedia whose surgical section included drawings of the instruments he used, roughly two hundred of them. Translated into Latin, it was read by European surgeons for centuries, and it is valued today because the pictures let historians see what the tools were.

The caliph's son al-Hakam II, who ruled from 961 to 976, was a collector of books who sent agents east to buy manuscripts. His court also produced the Calendar of Córdoba in 961, which will appear again when we look at farming.

The strong man

When al-Hakam II died in 976, his heir Hisham II was a boy. Power passed to a court official, Ibn Abi Amir, who removed rivals one by one and ruled in the boy's name. He took the title al-Mansur, "the victorious," and Christian writers called him Almanzor. He kept the caliph in seclusion and relied on Berber troops recruited from North Africa and on slave soldiers of European origin, known as saqaliba. He also led many campaigns into the Christian north, and in 997 he sacked Santiago de Compostela and had its bells carried to Córdoba by Christian captives, where they reportedly hung as lamps in the mosque. He spared the apostle's tomb. To his subjects he was a hero; to the northern kingdoms he was a scourge.

The collapse

Al-Mansur died in 1002, and his son Abd al-Malik ruled successfully until 1008. Another son, nicknamed Sanchuelo, went further and had himself named heir to the caliphate itself. For many Córdobans this was too much. In 1009 a revolt overthrew him, and the city fell into a long civil war, the fitna. Berber regiments, Córdoban crowds and slave generals each backed their own candidate, and factions even hired Christian soldiers from Castile and Catalonia. Caliphs were made and murdered in quick succession. Finally, in 1031, the notables of Córdoba abolished the caliphate and governed the city as a council. Across al-Andalus, local commanders and families had already taken power for themselves.

Worked example: why did the caliphate fall so fast?

Three explanations compete. The first blames the army: by relying on troops recruited from outside, loyal to their paymasters rather than to the people they ruled, the caliphs built a force that could seize power whenever pay or patronage failed. The second blames al-Mansur, who drained the dynasty's authority by ruling for a figurehead, so that when his family overreached, nobody remained to defend the caliph's office. The third points to money: the endless campaigns and the costly army demanded heavy taxes, and the provinces had little reason to stay loyal once Córdoba weakened.

These explanations fit together. A state whose armed force is cut off from the society it rules can look strong for a long time, as Córdoba did under Abd al-Rahman III and al-Mansur. Its strength depends on one capable person at the top. When that person dies, there is nothing underneath to hold it up. The lesson applies far beyond medieval Spain: government that rests on consent and shared institutions tends to survive bad rulers, while government that rests on a hired army does not.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was Madinat al-Zahra?
2. What happened to Madinat al-Zahra in 1010?
3. Which book did Hasdai ibn Shaprut help put into Arabic?
4. What did al-Zahrawi's surgical writing include?
5. What did al-Mansur do at Santiago de Compostela in 997?
6. Who held real power for the young caliph Hisham II?
7. What did the notables of Córdoba do in 1031?
8. What happened to Otto I's envoy John of Gorze in Córdoba?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia